If you are a football fan or even appreciate/understand the game, even if you don't like him as a player or individual person, you can understand why he is "all that". There are very few quarterbacks who can consistently do what he does. Ever watch him drive the ball down the field 3 possessions in a row in less than 5 minutes to come back and win the game? There are very few QB's that can do that. He does it consistently every season. It helps that he has a good O-line, but even a good o-line can't do it themselves, and honestly, the Patriots offense isn't even usually ranked the best. I've only know of about 5 NFL QB's ever, that could do what Brady does on a consistent basis. Maybe even less.
I don't rate football players by their looks, so I can't help you there.
ETA: And I don't even "like" quarterbacks....I have much more respect, as a whole, for the no-glory, no-shining-star, down in the trenches every play, linemen. I tend to watch the line on a play more than who is throwing or catching the ball. Gives a whole 'nother view to the game.