I've had a long journey getting my husband completely on board with Disney, but here are some things that worked for us:
-Slow down your pace. I'm a commando tourer too, but it definitely doesn't work for him, so I try to compromise. (We try to get to the parks early, move quickly for the first couple hours, and then go at a relaxed pace the rest of the day.)
-Stay at a resort that interests him. We always stayed at values, but then tried POR Riverside. DH loved it. Actually, just make sure you stay on site. Not having to drive was a big plus for him.
-Go to restaurants that would interest him. Coral Reef and Saana are great breaks. We also like to schedule a TS lunch, so it's a guaranteed a/c break in the middle of the day.
-Go during slower/cooler times. Just makes everyone happier.
-Try some special events. DH LOVES Food and Wine. He also enjoys Living with the Land, so next trip he is looking forward to doing the Behind the Seeds tour.
-Have kids (well, Disney shouldn't be your main reason, but...). Apparently he tolerated my excitement about going to Disney, but he cannot deprive our son of the pure joy he experiences there. Seriously, we have a one year old who has already been twice (we only live a few hours away), and DH is all on board (and even excited?!?!) to go back in the fall for Food and Wine and get FL Resident Seasonal Passes. Plus I mentioned going back for Candlelight Processional for one night, and his reply was "Only one night?" I consider this an ultimate victory!