After I was old enough to appreciate it, it was a favorite of mine. I liked the way it smelled in there, and the giant light-up snowflake in the wait area. Going with the "extinct attractions" theme...Tahitian Terrace, or Aladdin's Oasis (when it was still a restaurant)?

The Small World "holiday" overlay is Christmas right? I mean, it's tough to tell with so many different holidays out there. I've never been during many of them. It's a tough choice because Christmas and Halloween are my two favorite holidays, but I suppose I'll choose the Chistmas holiday because it is so beautifully themed. The Halloween one, while great in its own right, isn't quite the Halloween theme I prefer. (Universal's Halloween Horror Nights fan)
Turtle Talk with Crush vs Princess' Meet & Greet
Maybe they could just keep the ride as it is, and hide some Pop-Up Ghosts behind some of the dolls...now THAT would be scary 
Disneyland Railroad or the Monorail?
Chip or Dale?
WYR ride.........Little Mermaid or Star Tours 2.0?
You are pardon but leave the churro aside I'd prefer the Kettle Corn.
TNP.......HM with an hour wait or walk on POTC?