Hi everyone. We just got back from visiting my in-laws who are staying in South Carolina till they figure out where to go and what to do while New Orleans is being rebuilt.
I haven't caught up yet, so I'll have to go back and read all the replies later today, hopefully Madison will take a nap.
Lissawynn, I would go ahead and move Jimmy to a mattress on the floor, with a bed rail on it. I wouldn't put him in a real bed like up high, but I'd just put the mattress on the floor with a rail on the side (and maybe the top/bottom too if it's not against a wall since they move so much. Madison hated her crib too but slept fine in our bed. It wasn't just about sleeping with us, cause she'd sleep fine in our bed without us in it too. In fact, she'd prefer it if we weren't in the bed because she likes the space to herself. We moved Madison to a toddler bed at 14 months and she did fine. She never fought us about going in the bed like she did the crib (she screamed like Jimmy so I know what you mean!). It came with a side rail and she's never fallen out. Even though it's the same size as her crib, I think she likes how it's not as confining, shecan get in/out on her own, less babyish. The only thing to be prepared for is that once he's walking (or maybe even sooner!) he'll probably climb out and come find you. Not a big deal for me, but if that will bother you keep it in mind. If he's in his own room, you could always just stick a baby gate at the door and let him roam around his room till he's tired and goes back to bed. Madison just comes to the side of our bed and either climbs in herself or gets picked up by me or my husband and spends the rest of the night with us. That's if she gets out of her bed at all, many nights she'll wake up, cry a few minutes, then go back to sleep in her own bed. For us, it was the best move we've made as it made bedtime so much easier.
ETA-I don't know the name of the bedrails we bought (we use them on the bed at my mom's house when we sleep there) but they come over the top of the mattress instead of just staying flush against the side of the mattress like most of them do. Okay, I found them, here's a link to what we bought so you can see how it's different than other bedrails.
Safety 1st Bedrails I mean I guess there's still a chance that they could get trapped, but because they go over the top of the mattress (and you can really tighten them to be a very snug fit) the risk seems slim to me. It does cut away some of the freedom of movement since they take away a couple of inches of the bed, but it's not that much IMO.