I can't believe I let this thread get to three pages before I had a chance to hop in on it!! With the exception of CSI, AI, and Survivor, I only watch home improvement type shows. I have been watching TS since season one (who remembers Alex McCloud as the host.... then she did that stupid Joe Millionaire show!). My neighbor and I had thought about applying to the show, but then a few things changed.....number one, we found out that you need to live a short distance to a Home Depot or Lowe's..... we live pretty far from the nearest one.... number two.... Hildi started acting crazy and the fear of ending up with her was too great!!!
My favorite shows are TS and Decorating Cents on HGTV. I don't do anything without a TIGHT budget. And they end up with some very pretty rooms on Decorating Cents with only $500! Plus I love their "Art and Architecture" segment.
I do like Clean Sweep and find it inspiring, but it is getting boring.... I am so tired of seeing people whine about getting rid of their "junk"! Then why did you apply to the show??? And if you were truly afraid that they would "make you" get rid of something you wanted to keep, then why didn't you move it out of the room before they arrived!! Like a recent show with the "wedding dress from a previous relationship gone sour". She should have known that they would want it GONE. And she is never going to get anything near market value for it at a yard sale. She should have Ebayed it!! Or at the very least sold it through the want ads or at a consignment store!
I do like WYWO, but a lot of the rooms lately have been "over the top" IMHO.
But on most of these shows my main question is.... WHY DO THESE ROOMS NEED A THEME??? Why does it have to be "Jungle Casual" or "How the West was Chic" (yuck)? Can't it just be a nice room?? I can understand leaning toward a particular design type.... french country, english cottage, american primitive, oriental/asian.... but must they all have such a strong theme statement?! I can honestly say that most of the rooms in my house have no specific THEME. Except for my son's room which is BUZZ LIGHTYEAR CASUAL!!!

.............................P