It really was.
Sweetie, am I remembering correctly that your daughter is around 3 years old?
I'm probably the worst person to talk to about this. My son has been every single year since he was born. The first time he went, he was about eight months old. Now that was a hard trip. But let me tell you something.
It is not about whether or not your daughter will remember. It's about whether or not you will.
I have made some incredible memories with my family in Disney World. And some of the best ones are from when we started taking my son. Now is it hard to have a toddler at Disney? Oh sure. But is it hard to have a toddler at home? Oh sure!
For me, it's not about what he'll remember, it's about what I will. And I know that I'm doing something that is important to me and my husband, and that's spending quality time together as a family. People seem to have this notion in their heads that because it's Disney World, it has to be the absolute, it must be perfect, it must be such and such. Seriously, do people ask you why you take your daughter to the zoo? Or to the beach? Or to the park? I mean, if they won't remember it, why do we do it?
To make them happy. To make us happy.
As far as finances, you know what you're comfortable with. And I'm a big proponent of time alone with my husband, too, but if you feel in your heart that you're going to spend the whole time missing her, then it's not worth it to leave her at home.
Sorry about the diatribe! I guess this is kind of a can of worms you've opened with me, because people have said the same thing to me. And in the words of LL, I say "PFFT!"
And on a side note, my son does remember our trips. He actually has an excellent memory in general. Just the other day, we were driving past Babies R Us, and he told me, "Aunt _______" and proceeded to tell me about how we met one of my sister in laws there.
That was over 2 years ago, when she was pregnant with my first niece. So is his memory pretty good? Yes. Does he remember things about Disney? Oh yes! And is it totally worth it to take your child even if they won't remember it? In my mind, yes. Because I will, and I do.
And if my as yet unspeakable birthday is teaching me anything, along with a whole new year, it's that life is too short to worry about what other people think and not just be who I am. I'm trying to put that into practice.
Go with your gut, and you can't go wrong.