Okay, this is totally OT, but I need some advice. Conservatives are generally careful with spending, so I figured this was the place to ask.

I am looking at my handy dandy charts that I made earlier tonight showing the rates of various WDW resorts with this new 7 for the price of 4 deal. Here's what I came up with for 3 adults, 8 nights in May, 8 day park hopper pass:
Caribbean Beach or Riverside (water view): $2,104.41
Animal Kingdom Lodge or Wilderness Lodge (standard view): $2,728.65
Wilderness Lodge (courtyard view): $3,000.60
Animal Kingdom Lodge (Savannah view): $3,122.49
Polynesian (Garden view): $3,422.28
We paid around $4,000 for our 7 day hopper tickets and 9 nights at WL (courtyard view) this May. So, I'm presented with a unique opportunity here. My parents and I go on two family vacations a year, and they pay (my parents are quite awesome, btw). WL in 2005 and 2008 was a graduation present to me, as they can't really afford that price for a resort. All of these prices above are well below what we paid last year. My dad asked the price of Riverside tonight, and I also tossed in the price for the Grand (which was $3,600) and the Poly, pointing out the difference between what he paid this year on the latter two.

I would love to go back to WL. I'm iffy about the Poly. But my dad has wanted to stay there since it opened. It's, for whatever reason, his Disney dream. Mine is a Magic Kingdom tower view room at the Contemporary, but I'm waiting on my imaginary lottery winnings to come in the mail before I ever even think about that.

My mom said he talked about the Poly all the time in the 70s when they got married. He talks about it hardly at all these days, dismissing it as too expensive.
So, question: Is the Poly worth is? Is garden view worth it? Has anyone stayed there? I'd be a happy clam staying in a Standard room at my beloved WL, but I'm wondering if I should do a wink, wink, nudge, nudge with my dad to get him to go with the Poly since he may never have another chance to stay there that cheaply.
If you had the above options, what would you do?