It looks like someone took a sledge hammer to the stalls. That does not look like normal wear and tear to me.
I agree. It appears some form of abuse would have had to occur in order for things to get to such a state.
But that leads me to a comment on the issue of maintenance. Our dues are certainly designed to maintain resorts to an acceptable level. The question is how the "acceptable level" is defined.
To repair the issues noted here would require:
* Close down the bathroom.
* Remove all of the hardware on the impacted stall(s).
* Repair the wall tile.
* Repair the ceiling drywall and any underlying supports that may be damaged.
* Paint, grout and otherwise "finish" the repairs.
* Replace all of the hardware.
Whether it's Disney fixing the bathroom or me repairing my own at home, that type of project is going to cost thousands of dollars--money which would come out of our dues.
If the room suffers similar abuse a dozen times per year and the goal is to keep the room in pristine condition, then we're going to pay for the repair a dozen times. And if those repeated repairs cause the maintenance staff to exceed their budget, then our dues will go up further.
It's difficult to truly get a feel for the state of the room with such close pictures. If the damage represents a danger, then obviously it should be repaired. But if there is no pending danger to guests and the issues are the type you really have to go looking for in order to find, it becomes more of a judgement call.
The wallpaper is an easy fix and I agree with others that the door was probably removed pending repairs.
As
DVC owners, we may all have the expectation that our dues are sufficient to pay for the
immediate repair of every loose tile, faded carpet and scratched tabletop, but I sincerely doubt that is the case.