What do you consider rough? We've all been up the Na Pali coast on Kauai when it's rough with no trouble. Would it be better or worst than that?
No experience in Hawaii for us.
Great specific question..... Totally variable but .....
What do I consider rough? You don't want to know. It funny how it's all relative. lol.
Some days the seas are 1 foot and wind variable at 5 knots.
Some days the seas are 6 feet with winds out of the NW at 20 knots.
Odds are sea state will be somewhere in between. duh.
What few mention is if sea state is unfavorable, you will not be sailing to St. John. It happens. Rarely though.
We have sailed on the what, 30 - 60 foot cats in 8 foot seas to St John. Brutal, yet memorable. Also been there in 6 inch seas too. Rare, but it happens. Funny thing is we don't recall that sailing. lol. Of course we are always on the little boat in high seas, and the big boat in small seas. Go figure.
You have to consider the vessel of conveyance to accurately determine your specific inquiry that are implied in the transfer.
Some are larger than others. Some are smaller. Also hundreds of passengers are conveyed weekly w/o any problem. Keep that in mind.
In others words, ignore my rant. lol.
As PP mentioned it is well worth the visit if you are willing to loose 2 hours travel time and play the sea state game. We choose that game every other time fwiw. And occasionally play it be ear at the last minute based on weather reports.
Of course some of our cat experiences are those that still resonate to this day. That is worth noting, as is my Sandy experience. Isn't all about unforgettable memories, is it not?
Oh, does that not involve high seas for all?
Also if sailing on the Fantasy with it's usual limited time in St Thomas, one must figure this timing into their schedule, IMO.
Good Luck to all, and may you have small seas.
