I don't remember pencils being so cheaply made when I was a kid, but they're a constant problem in my classroom -- students sharpen and sharpen and sharpen. It takes forever, and disrupts class.
I only volunteer in the classroom a couple of hours a week, but the quality of pencils drives
me nuts, I can't imagine how bad it is for the teachers! Lead falls out, lead is crooked, so there is a thin film of wood over one side of even a sharp pencil point...

And these are yellow pencils, not the cutesy kind. Have no idea if they are American or foreign-made, though.
I just wish that the schools would put together packages of items they want for each grade and let the PTA sell them for a slight profit. I would certainly buy them to save the gas from having to hunt down the items. I imagine that they could order/buy in bulk as a non-profit and sell at a decent rate- this would take care of some of the fund raising and making sure they have the supplies that are needed.
Our school used to do this through a company called EduKit, but had to stop this year for two reasons. 1. Budget shortfalls created such havoc that they didn't how many teachers they'd have at each grade level, what specials classes would be offered, and what supplies would be needed until far past the deadline. 2. Even though we used an outside company, it still requires quite a bit of volunteer time to administer the program, and our volunteers are stretched so thin already, even the PTA had to cut out some of their previous events, fundraisers and services simply due to lack of help.
Why? Why are basic bathroom necessities not provided by the district? On another note, I stock the bathroom (and soda machine) in my business out of my own pocket too. Toilet paper, paper towels, soap, laundry detergent, cleaning supplies, tissues, soda for the Coke machine. It gets written off a business expense. I don't ask my students or their families to supply these items, and yeah it's a pretty big investment but it's the business I'm in so I do it.
Not knocking teachers...just "the system".

In your case, and that of any other business, you can raise prices if you cannot afford to stock your bathroom, right? Public schools cannot do that. They are stuck with the budget given to them by the district, which is stuck with the funds it receives from state and local taxes. Our elementary school's site-based budget barely covers the teachers and administrators salaries, utilities, etc. There is not a lot left for bathroom and cleaning supplies, so all year long, they ask for donations of Clorox wipes, paper cups, TP, etc. (Wipes, tissues and hand sanitizer are on the supply list.) It was the principal's choice to keep staffing up and rely on donations for much of this, but we live in a pretty wealthy district where many parents are willing to help out. In other districts, I'd guess that the decision might have been made to let another teacher go, and increase class sizes or do away with art or PE, if they didn't think the parents would pitch in to provide supplies.
As for the OP, I don't mind when they ask for brands. I know Rose Art crayons and markers are junk. But dd was asked for three spiral notebooks (80 or more sheets) this year. All Target had were 70 sheets (other than cutesy ones that cost 4 to 8 times as much.)

I bought them, because I also know that when she brings them home at the end of the year, each one will have about 10-20 sheets filled in, and if she really uses up the 70 sheets in one year, I will be happy to buy more notebooks part way through the year.
