I love getting pins. Anything "Disney World" specific I get. Any ride I love I get a pin for. Always gotta get one for the resort and for the year (although the 2015 ones are ugly as sin). I have a few rare ones like Gaston's Tavern, Trader Sam's, Mickey's Philharmagic, Epcot's 30th Anniversary, The Adventurers Club, and New Fantasyland.
I like to get a little special something from my favorite attractions or places. I've got a mini replica of the Splash Mountain poster that you see when you walk into the Magic Kingdom. I've got the new Memento Mori portrait and a statue of the Hitchhiking Ghosts for the Haunted Mansion. A little Viking on a boat to honor the Maelstrom. A mini "Magic Lamp" from Morocco. A yeti snow globe for Expedition Everest. A nice Monorail mug. A "Mine! Mine! Mine! photo holder from The Seas. A Spaceship Earth and Tree of Life mug. A Tiki cup and a ceramic Dole Whip for Adventureland. A mini Lumiere and a Gaston's Tavern stein for New Fantasyland.
I could never find anything with "Main Street, USA" on it, but when we were waiting for Wishes this month we were wandering around the railroad station and found Main Street pressed pennies! Best 51 cents I ever spent!
I fell head-over-heels in love with Animal Kingdom Lodge, so I got a bunch of stuff from their gift shop. A tribal statue handmade in Kenya. A mini wooden giraffe. An African tribal drum. An AKL magnet.
Oh, and you know what else is a nice little souvenir... those Disney Conservation Hero pins that you get when you donate to their conservation fund. I've got one from The Seas and one from AKL. Cost a buck each.
Plus all the free stuff you can get from the resorts. I kept my AKL Wildlife Spotting Guide and took a Wines of Africa pamphlet (plus a bunch of other little things over the years!).