I think no matter who you ask, you will get different opinions about different restaurants. There are some that I absolutely love, like Rose & Crown. However we have eaten there and couldn't wait to leave. There are others like the Chefs in France, that others don't like, but I've had good food.
I used to like Tutto Italia, but the last couple of times we ate there, it was terrible. Via Napoli has always been good, but others don't like it.
No matter how many people you ask, you are bound to get that many different answers as to what's good and what's not at Epcot or anywhere else. I am one who also loves Tony's in the Magic Kingdom. And judging by how many other people are waiting when I check in at the desk, there are a lot of other people that share that opinion. But I continually see it also being bad mouthed as being terrible. It depends on what you like. And it can be different every trip.