***ROCKSTAR: Supernova*** (spoilers welcome)

[Pooh Girl 71]

I am. Dave Navarro is hot (my message was too short )

 

[SillyMe]

Me too.

 

[Pooh Girl 71]

Well that was a site better than last night's performance. I didn't think he was throaty enough to really pull off Jim Morrison though.

 

[MushyMushy]

It was a good bit better. I hope it's enough to save him.

What did you all think of Lucas's behavior in the house?

 

[MushyMushy]

I don't know this song that Phil's doing. I like it!

 

[Pooh Girl 71]

hehe he's one cocky son of a gun isn't he? I kind of like him. He sure has a rock star vybe about him.

 

[Pooh Girl 71]

I just knew that a Duran Duran song would be the kiss of death.

 

[declansdad]

Wrong choice, Chris was still the weakest.


Couldn't they find someone besides Brooke Burke to host this show? Man she is terrible. She makes Ben Mulroney (Canadian Idol) look like the world's best host.

 

[mickey4ver]

Wrong choice, Chris was still the weakest.


Couldn't they find someone besides Brooke Burke to host this show? Man she is terrible. She makes Ben Mulroney (Canadian Idol) look like the world's best host.

I think she isn't there to host, but to look pretty......

I really wanted Chris to go...

 

[declansdad]

I think she isn't there to host, but to look pretty......

I really wanted Chris to go...

Hard to pay attention to her being pretty when she is as dumb as a post.

 

[mickey4ver]

Hard to pay attention to her being pretty when she is as dumb as a post.

a lot of men wouldn't mine that she is dumb as a post, when she wears clothes like she does

I'm still wondering which direction this Supernova Band is going to go by the way they are judging the singers.....

 

[Crankyshank]

Supposedly Supernova's sound is going to be a bit like Velvet Revolver meets the Clash.

 

[Todd&Copper]

Supposedly Supernova's sound is going to be a bit like Velvet Revolver meets the Clash.

Oh. OK.
Well, to me, that is not terribly helpful. Maybe they should give us a brief demo, part of a song they are working on, anything.

I didn't watch last night, but I was surprised to hear that Mangy was not in the bottom three. I really thought he'd be there.

 

[spacemountain]

I liked Matt and didn't want him to go home. But he had to know that this was the moment to prove to them that he could sing harder rock, and he didn't.

 

[mickey4ver]

Supposedly Supernova's sound is going to be a bit like Velvet Revolver meets the Clash.

hmm...I like Velvet Revolver....

I'm having a hard time though thinking which one of these singers will "fit" because I don't know what Supernova is going to record...with INXS, I knew their "sound" and music...interesting anyway

Yeah, the whole Duran Duran was a death song, but he did things "his" way instead of being told what to sing I guess. Personally, I thought Phil was awful, even though Matt didn't follow instructions and Phil should have been the goner.

Remember last year, JD was the "bad kid in the house" with saying things about the others? seems Lucas is going to take over that role and you remember where JD ended up.......

 

[TurboKitty]

....mumble, grumble...take #3 from my buggy pos computer...

First of all, I need to apologize to the competitors for my overly harsh critique of song choices. I wasn't aware they were given a pool of songs from the band, and thought they each had more control over how to best present their voical talents.

Chris - LA Woman - Color me...disapponted. You claim you can sing. You claimed you would make this song your own. You channeled a pale anemic version of Jim Morrison. Were you trying to impersonate his ghost? The writhing on stage was pathetic, not charismatic. The spitting water at the audience made you seem a jerk, regardless of where you've seen it prior. You should be thanking Matt for shooting himself in the foot, because I think you deserve to be out more than he does.

Phil - ??- I am not familiar with the band or the song you did. I liked the melody and what little of the lyrics I could hear over the music and actually understand, I did like. I can't fairly judge how well you performed this song, but I hope you find some some strength to back up your vocals so we can hear you.

Matt - Planet Earth - Boy-o, WHAT were you thinking??! The band already told you, they liked your voice and what you did with Yellow. The asked you to bring them something raw and ugly and show them you know how to RAWK, and you dredge up Duran freaking Duran??! Myself, I thought you had the best voice out of this week's bottom three, but I have to agree that you probably aren't right for this group.

I also gotta give Matt props for one of the classiest exit interviews I've seen in a while. What a good guy.

 

[Crankyshank]

I'm still laughing at the Duran Duran choice
Although to be fair it did rock more than Coldplay

 

[Sandy22]

I lliked Magni much better this week

 

[MushyMushy]

Hi guys! It's time!

Magni did much better this week, dontcha think?

Not too sure of Jenny at this moment, but I'll hold judgment until she finishes the song.

ETA, I see that they liked it, but I didn't. I think it might have been better if she would have punked it up with a driving beat.

 

[Pooh Girl 71]

Magni was much better. Didn't care for Jenny at all.

I forgot the other chick's name. I didn't care too much for her version of Violet. No pain in the voice.