I have been meaning to update with our experience since I so appreciate all the feedback on here before we went.
We were there on Friday, Dec. 2nd and did the Aladdin package. We checked in for our dinner at 6pm and sat in the area to eat it - they brought it to our table. My husband and I both had the lasagna, and I thought it was good - not great, but not bad at all. I appreciated the bottled Diet Coke since I could take it with me. It was a bit chilly that night, and the seating area is covered, but not exactly heated.
Our fast pass was for the 10:30 showing. We wandered down there earlier than I thought we would. I didn't want to waste time waiting/steaking out a spot, but we were pretty worn out by about 9:45 anyway. We sat down across from Small World in the area shown in the picture up thread by Disney Dad ADL. Here is where I was surprised. We could have stayed where we were without the fast pass because for this showing, on this night, the 10:30 only had about 25 people who purchased the package. Therefore, the roped off area for us was downsized to the area at street level (to the left as you look at the pic by Disney Dad). I commented to the CM - "Wow, the reserved viewing area shrunk...." trying to sound lighthearted, but curious. He said they didn't have many reservations so they downsized like to 25 % of normal I would guess. We got right along the rope at street level, and ended up standing....great view, but ONLY because the numbers of people viewing the 10:30 that night down by small world, it probably wasn't necessary. BUT HOW DO YOU KNOW???
cptmemo who posted above must have gone to the early show that same night - and it was a WHOLE different story. It was very busy in the park that day, and PTN had not shown all week.
Price wise I don't think it was a huge loss. If you are going to go to BB anyway, I would do the package. The WOC dessert party was way more money - but the payoff was well worth it - so that panned out exactly as it should have.
Bottom line is you just never know. BUT again, down by Small World at 10:30 - you may have done just as well chancing it - on this particular night.