I've been to POP twice. Got the 50s the first time, then requested it the 2nd time. I like it for the theme, the pool is nice and big, and the 50s music is nice. I decided to request it again for my trip in Sept. It will be my GF's first time ever at WDW!
We'll probably take a walk over to AoA and grab a bite there, too.
It looks like, on the map, that there is a smoking area right where you would walk from 50s to the main hall. Is this an issue? I wouldn't want to have to walk past smoke every time.