Poor guy suffers from affluenza

Uncle Remus

Raconteur / can't name 'em Jeb
Joined
Jul 23, 2006
Messages
13,383
A Texas teenager killed four people while driving drunk. His attorney chose an unusual defense to keep him out of prison.

He got drunk then jumped behind the wheel of his pickup truck and plowed down four people in a drunken haze. So why isn't Ethan Couch behind bars? Keep in mind he's just 16, too young to legally drive with any alcohol in his system. In this case, his blood alcohol measured point 2-4. Three times the legal limit in Texas. Eric Boyles' wife and daughter were both killed:

"We had over 180 years of life taken, future life, not 180 years lived, but 180 years of future life taken and two of those were my wife and daughter," said Boyles.

Investigators say surveillance tape shows Couch and his friends stealing beer from a Walmart store in June. Then they got drunk at a party. Leaving there, police say Couch gunned his pickup going nearly 70 miles per hour in a 40 mph zone.

Just about 400 yards down the street, he slammed into Holly and Shelby Boyles, who had stopped to help Breanna Mitchell fix a flat tire. Youth pastor Brian Jennings was driving by and had also stopped to help.

All of them were killed.

In one of the most bizarre defense strategies we've ever heard of, Couch's attorneys blamed the boy's parents for his behavior that night. All because of how they raised him. A psychologist - and defense witness - testified Couch was a product of something he called "affluenza." A lifestyle where wealth brought privilege and there were no consequences for bad behavior.

That psychologist cited one instance when Couch, then 15, was caught in a parked pickup with a naked, 14 year old girl who was passed out. Couch was never punished, the psychologist said. He also testified the teenager was allowed to drink at a very young age, and even began driving at just 13.

Prosecutors fought for a 20-year sentence. But the defense argued Couch needed treatment, not prison.

The judge agreed and gave Couch 10-years probation plus time in alcohol rehab. No prison. She told the court she believes Couch can be rehabilitated if he's away from his family and given the right treatment.

He'll likely end up at this pricey rehab center in Newport Beach California. His father has agreed to pay the half-a-million dollars or so it will cost.

http://www.khon2.com/news/national-news/affluenza-defense-in-fatal-teen-drunk-driving-case

I wonder if attorneys will use this case as a defense for any further crimes this kid commits. :rolleyes:
 
Well if the judge is going to take the defense, I would jail the parents. She is essentially blaming them.
 

Well, it's come full circle from "he can't be held accountable because he had a deprived childhood!. :confused3:confused:
Now having too much gives you a get-out-of-jail card. :sad2:
This country is going to heck in a handbasket, to paraphrase my dear departed Dad.:headache:
 
Ginny Favers said:
And so letting him off is the way to go? SOMEONE needs to finally give him consequences for his behavior!!

Excellent point. He basically is getting away with murder. Of course he will likely violate his probation so at least there's that.

I have a feeling if he were poor and grew up with parents who let him run wild, he would have been tried as an adult and had the book thrown at him.
 
Wait a minute- so the consequence of committing a crime because you have never had consequences is that you get a slap on the wrist and no real consequence? How is that going to teach him? It further perpetuates the problem as now he learns he can get away with things through the court, too. What about the kids who commit crimes because they came from broken homes or their parents didn't give a care to discipline them? Will that be a valid defense now, too? It is essentially the same thing.
 
This case is probably one of the most disgusting things I've heard in awhile.

I guess in Texas (if your Daddy is filthy rich) you get a free pass to end 4 lives with no consequences.
Oh, I forgot. He's been sent to an extremely expensive "treatment" program in Cali. I wonder if his "therapy" will include surfing and massages? :rolleyes1

Consequences??? Don't be silly. Those are only for the poor folks.
 
So this is what society has come to? Making up "conditions" as an excuse for killing people? :headache: :sad2:
 
This happened less than a mile from my parents' house. It was horrific. I think about all those families every single time we drive by the scene where the "accident" happened. I look into the yard to see if I see the man whose wife and daughter's lives were taken right in his own front yard. One day there was just a single lawn chair sitting in his yard facing the road, and it made me so sad for him.

Several of the families of the dead and injured (including some who were riding with the drunk kid) have sued the parents and their company.

I am beyond disgusted by this sentencing.
 
I'd really like to use some swear words, but I know they'd be starred out, so I won't bother.

At what age can kids stop blaming their parents and take some damn responsibility for their own actions? :mad::mad:

That judge is a joke. So the kid has never had to be held accountable for his actions? Let's keep the pattern rolling.

What an idiot.
 
Excellent point. He basically is getting away with murder. Of course he will likely violate his probation so at least there's that.

I have a feeling if he were poor and grew up with parents who let him run wild, he would have been tried as an adult and had the book thrown at him.

This
 
Disgusting. The victim's families are the true ones suffering, not this spoiled little brat.
 
There are so many things wrong with that statement, I don't know where to begin. I was just reading about this case this morning - the whole thing is horrible. Peace and blessings on the families of those who were killed by this little punk. I can't and don't want to imagine their pain.

If I were that kid's parents, I would be MORTIFIED to have, on the record for time and eternity, that my child was given a pass because of the way we'd raised him. But apparently they're not the kind of people who would be bothered by that.

I was raised in a fairly affluent household. My parents raised us, however, to not be bratty, entitled or the like; any of that behavior was nipped in the bud ASAP. We worked from the time we were 14-15 years old at restaurants, babysat, etc; our needs were taken care of, but anything else (movies with friends, clothes beyond what was bought at the beginning of the school year, entertainment expenses, etc) was paid for with our own money. My dad also had a saying (which I think he took from an episode of the Cosby show): Your mother and I have money - you have nothing. A pointed way of saying, it's up to you to make your way in this world and although we are there to love and help you, you're not riding our bank account for your whole life.

I only bring up the personal info about myself to illustrate a point that not all children raised in affluence are bratty, entitled little monsters. Some are, to be sure as evidenced by this charming fellow. And his parents should be ashamed of themselves.
 
Completely terrible. And, here's the thing, if this had been a young Black man, he would have gone to jail for decades, if not for life.
 


Disney Vacation Planning. Free. Done for You.
Our Authorized Disney Vacation Planners are here to provide personalized, expert advice, answer every question, and uncover the best discounts. Let Dreams Unlimited Travel take care of all the details, so you can sit back, relax, and enjoy a stress-free vacation.
Start Your Disney Vacation
Disney EarMarked Producer






DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Add as a preferred source on Google

Back
Top Bottom