I mean the vacation is Disney - your pool day is to relax. A beach trip is to relax. Disney is Disney.
FP+ was stressful. You still had to wait on standard lines.
Genie+ was the change - you paid $ but you only had to wait on a line that didn’t HAVE Genie+ if you used it correctly. So much less phone time day of, much easier to plan (FP+ had such spordic times which often conflicted with dining!!). Genie+ was chronological order!!!
Now yes, there were a VERY small handful of rides that would sell out before 9, when you could also book (like many offsiters). Maybe SDD day would force you to be up at 7.
But not pre-planning with the old system means you didn’t know how to use it nor spent the time to learn it. Historically it was easy to find out what rides had immediate returns and what were later returns (thrill data). You could know that historically, on this day of your visit) by 11am you could still get a jungle cruise return anywhere between 3:45 and 4:15. Book it, go to your noon lunch ressie, book your next LL at 1pm. It worked well because it allowed data to be collected. This new system is a free for all, all based on personal decisions.
For those that want to get their monies worth (because 3 rides under genie+ is EXTREMELY LOW), there is no planning because we don’t know what times people will pick, nor give up because it no longer works, and even for rides that you could immediately hop on, like its a small world, pirates, dumbo, etc, this will now cause major conflicts day of with previously booked dining because the times will be all over the place (it’s no longer going to be released in chronological order, people can book whenever). More so, you could effectively use genie+ if you wanted to just wait the 2 hour rule and stack. You could line up a good amount of rides, again in chronological order, by evening. This new system does not allow this.
It will be harder to plan, except for those that are okay with using it for only 3 or 4 rides (why???). I don’t know what many people’s personal lives look like, but having to work also plays a role with now having to spend time doing this on a potential workday. Sure, I loved to pre plan but I like to after my kids go to sleep, not being forced to tell my boss I’m going to be late because I have to book Disney things, of which I’m already taking off for a week later and just was late 2 months ago because it was Disney dining day. It’s too much.