The mixing and matching of patterns and florals was much closer to turn of the century type decor than you're giving credit for IMO.
![teeth :teeth: :teeth:](http://www.disboards.com/data/smilies/teeth.gif)
And I don't think you can say that it wasn't unique - at least I've seen little like it elsewhere. But think more widspread - Disney without a doubt has built a reputation on attention to detail.
Disney also has an obligation to provide rooms which meet 21st century expectations for Deluxe hotel and timeshare accommodations. Nobody wants to pay Disney prices to stay in the equivalent of grandma's Atlantic seaboard cottage which hasn't been refurnished in 100 years.
But no - I don't know if BCV was that good when it was designed. What I'm referring to is a hope that some of the resorts that didn't have as much theme would get at least something a little stand out in the refurbs like the detail theming that we've seen at VWL, THV, Aulani, AKV, VGC and even BLT. This refurb for BCV is fine. Just not Disney fine IMO. I'm just back from BWV and feel the same way. It's nice. Hampton Inn nice. But seeing spaceship earth from the room added theme.
It goes without saying that some themes have a greater level of...distinctiveness...than others. The faux wood-carved furniture of AKV is unmistakeable. The modern look of Contemporary and BLT.
But resorts like BoardWalk and Beach Club are--quite simply--rather bland by comparison. Research cape cod / eastern seaboard type furnishings and you'll see exactly what Disney has delivered in both of these properties: white moldings with light colored walls, wood floors, painted kitchen cabinets, light colored fabrics, a mixture of natural wood and painted furniture.
Most--if not all--of the furniture is undoubtedly custom made. The dining table, the living room murphy bed, desks & nightstands with integrated electrical and USB.
Do BLT and BCV reflect trends which are now commonplace in the hospitality industry? Yes, of course. Does that automatically mean they are not true to the resort theme? Of course not.
As for quality, over the years I've seen many reports and photos of people entering newly-renovated rooms only to find stained carpets, scratched walls, broken cabinets and other damage.
Speaking as someone familiar with wood floors and laminates, yeah, they're gonna scratch under heavy use (and unavoidable abuse.) Even the best materials. Scratches can often be masked with the proper cleaning solution / cover-up.
Personally I still think it's a better material choice in those high-traffic villa living spaces. Between the shoes, food & drink, suitcases, luggage carts and other stain-producers, the laminate will hold up much better than carpet. Housekeeping rarely has time to properly deep-clean carpets, leaving most guests exposed to months worth of stains, dirt and bacteria.