What aren't you sure about? An offer came on board. An offer that really pushed a lot of people to OL. A dozen or more of us were asking questions on this exact thread about the offer because there were a few kinks. Ie. one of them was John coming on and telling us how the offer would go since there was nothing about the two free visits for life on the buying page. And many of us wondered where it would be in writing for us. He came on and cleared that up. I asked how long the offer was? Others questions were answered about paying periods etc.
Most of us knew the offer wouldn't be there for a really long time. Of course. But none of us had an inkling it would be gone in 24 hours. Nor did John, of course.
This is no way a "down with John"

post. I read many a post about how wonderful he is. And how tough this must have been to realize how this offer affected his original clients. (and I signed up to be a BETA member: our date just came too late; and like I've said the two of us see OL in a very different way - not just the money end; and this offer did push things a bit forward)
This is a place for us to come on and say what we thought. It would seem silly to hash out all the bits and pieces, ask when the offer is until, get an answer that doesn't seem like any minute and then come on and say "wow John's great. A new offer is coming up. Wow, it's a shame the great offer is gone from the site. I have no feelings about that." That's not how my feelings or thoughts work.
And honestly for the people who in a 24 hour period were trying to get a handle on OL, and the offer itself, my disappointment was twofold. One at myself for not just signing up and going back and forth with my SO later about it. And two, and I feel very strongly about it, that there was at least a 24 hour alert that he needed to close it down. Because come on we never had an inkling that it would be gone this weekend. Just a courtesy warning; this is business by no means an obligation.
John himself said this offer pushed a lot of people on the fence over to OL. Fantastic. But there were quite a few of us who were just ironing things out in a 24 hour period, came back on to sign up and gone.
So call me human but that's a disappointment. One can have disappointment and still regognize that many find John an exemplary human being in many ways and business owner who wants to take care of his clients. They do not have to incongruent.