Official American Idol Season 4 Thread

[KristaTX]

Mikayla (sp?) reminds me of a young, goofy Barbra Streisand.

Thank you! That's what I said last week and no one here seemed to think that about her .

 

[2bemarried]

Carrie and Nadia were my favorites. I also have to say that Aloha surprised me. I wasn't expecting to like her so much. I was very disappointed in Sarah. We have high hopes for her in NC since Clay and Fantasia did so well

I'm in the 50% of viewers that think Mikalah is ANNOYING! She reminds me of the annoying girlfriend from Friends...the one with the horrible laugh.

 

[sweet angel]

Thank you! That's what I said last week and no one here seemed to think that about her .

Sorry! I didn't see your post about that...or maybe I did and that' what made me think it. Nope...I don't think I saw it.

 

[KristaTX]

Oh, I wasn't complaining, sweet angel . I'm just glad someone else sees the resemblance .

 

[sweet angel]

I'm in the 50% of viewers that think Mikalah is ANNOYING! She reminds me of the annoying girlfriend from Friends...the one with the horrible laugh.

Janice.

 

[Tinkbell]

Overall, I was not as impressed with the girls tonight as much as I was with the guys last night. But my favorites were: Carrie, Nadia and Aloha.

I agree 100%. Those were the only girls who stood out to me tonight. I was really surprised by Nadia. I didn't think she'd go in that direction and it totally rocked.

 

[chimera]

Let's take that emotionally abusive father down a peg or two and see Scott go far. However, I just can't get past the idea that he looks like a serial killer!

I'm glad I'm not the only one that thinks that. The guy has an amazing voice, but he scares me a bit.

I love Nadia and her Justin Guarini hair! She seems to command the stage!

I was never a Fran Drescher fan, so I'm also one that finds Mikalah annoying.

And I'm rooting for the FL girls...Vonell (sp?) and Jessica!

 

[ValerieK]

Overall, I was not as impressed with the girls tonight as much as I was with the guys last night. But my favorites were: Carrie, Nadia and Aloha.

I agree with this also.

 

[Cindy B]

Its been 40 minutes and I still cant get through for Nadia... Please power dial for me.

I actually thought Vonzell was good too!

 

[damo]

You could judge by the reaction of the guys, which girls really stuck it.

 

[Tasha+Scott]

Okay, I may be in the minority but I think the girls did just as well as the guys...maybe better. I only liked a few of the guys last night and I felt the same way about the girls tonight.

Anyway, my favorites are Carrie, Vonzell, Amanda, and Nadia. I did not like Sarah much and I absolutely can NOT stand Mikalah! I pray she is cut, she grates on my nerves way too much!

I also noticed Constanine looking bored but I sort of think that was b/c he thinks he is better than the competition. He just has that conceited look in his eyes sometimes, but who knows?

 

[Cindy B]

Mikalah, yuck!

It looked like she got collogen shots in her lips. They were terrible.

 

[Tina]

Nadia was just plain awesome. DH voted for her over and over until his fingers got tired.

 

[Cookie55]

Count me in as part of the 50% who find Mikalah annoying. Will someone from the other 50% please identify themselves? Otherwise I think we're going to have to increase the percentage for those who are "annoyed."

 

[palmtreegirl]

Just got done watching...

Vonzell- Looked really cute, not a fan of the song but I thought she sounded pretty good.
Amanda- Finally figured out who she reminds me of, a young Jamie Gertz. Not this song again, ugh......would like to see her stick around to do another song.
Janay- That girl looked scared to death, didn't think her performance was very good.
Carrie- One of the best of the night.
Sara- just not good.
Melissa- Horizontal stripes are a bad choice, especially for TV. Weak performance.
Nadia- One of the best of the night, great style, great performance.
Celina- Zzzzzzzzzzzzz.
Mikayla- Call Fran Drescher and get them together for a sitcom but I'm not sure she's a singer. Simon was dead right about the love/hate.
Lindsey- Pretty girl but Zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz.
Jessica-didn't like this at all.
Aloha- Oh please go Aloha, I really didn't like her at all.

My votes will go to.....Carrie and Nadia! I thought they were the best by far.

Who I'd like to see go home- Aloha and Sara.

Anyone else notice Anthony had purple hair tonight?

I thought overall the girls were better then those boys.

 

[mouseclick1]

I didn't think the girls would do as well as the guys did, but I thought Carrie and Nadia were great! Maybe I'm confusing Nadia with someone else, but wasn't she the one who wasn't going to go through with it because she missed her child?

I don't find Mikalah cute or entertaining at all. I would like to see her go.

 

[damo]

Couldn't believe it when Simon said that in his next life he wanted to come back as Amanda's microphone!!! I think it was Amanda.

 

[macraven]

an hour after the show was over, i could not tell you which lady stood out for me.


i believe the real talent is with the guys this season.

none of the gals impressed me enough to spend time on the phone to vote tonight.

looking forwards to wednesday..................i have no idea which females will leave......can only guess the two guys that will.

 

[julia & nicks mom]

an hour after the show was over, i could not tell you which lady stood out for me.


i believe the real talent is with the guys this season.

none of the gals impressed me enough to spend time on the phone to vote tonight.

looking forwards to wednesday..................i have no idea which females will leave......can only guess the two guys that will.

I think that is so funny - My DH and I really liked the girls better - that proves that everyone certainly likes different things!!!

 

[Philadisney]

I didn't think the girls would do as well as the guys did, but I thought Carrie and Nadia were great! Maybe I'm confusing Nadia with someone else, but wasn't she the one who wasn't going to go through with it because she missed her child?

i don't think so, i think that woman actually did go home. i don't remember her name.

it's quarter to midnight and i've yet to be able to get through for nadia, jessica, or vonzell! wow!