Middle school child incident, thoughts please

sharlon

<b><Font color=blue>2008 DisCup Nascar Champ</COLO
Joined
Dec 22, 2003
Messages
3,704
I would love opinions of my Dis friends. Sorry for the length.

Yesterday after school my DD11 had to work the concession stand at the middle school football game. This is something that is done by the student council representatives. The game was a makeup game, so it was very last minute. Anyway, she stayed after school, worked on homework, then opened and worked the concessions. The notice I received from the teacher in charge was that the game would end around 7:15, but if it was early, she would call. No problem!

So at 7:00 I pile her sister and brother into the car and off we go. As we are leaving the house, I open my cell phone and notice a voicemail. That's weird, as my phone was in the house with me and it had not rang. We live in the mountains, so on occasion that will happen. I check the messages and it is my DD11 letting me know the game was going to be done early and I should pick her up in 10 minutes. Too bad she called at 6:26. I was so upset. Why didn't she call the house, as she was told to.

About half way to the school, my cell phone rings and it is DD11, I tell her that I am on my way and that I had just gotten her message. When I get to the school I find my eleven year old child in the dark, alone.

Apparently, when she was told to call to let me know the game would be done early, she was told to borrow another child's phone as the school office was locked and she couldn't use that phone. Problem here is that the PRINCIPAL (who has the key) told her this. The only child who had a phone she could borrow had restrictions on her cell, and it could only be used to call Verizon numbers, so DD11 couldn't call our house. Since when do middle schools count on all children having cell phones!

When I got to the school and my child was outside in the dark, alone, there were adults in the building, but she had to be outside. :confused3 The band director had seen her on his way out and had let her use his phone to make the second call. Why DD11 was not allowed to sit inside the building boggles my mind.

As an aside, this school is out in the country between two suburbs. There is nothing else around except cow fields. And, my DD11 was SCARED.

I have emailed the principal (without pointing fingers directly at her) and asked for some explanation. My question to you all is am I being ridiculous in thinking that the school should have done a better job of making sure that DD11 could contact a parent? Also, what do you think about her being left outside alone?
 
Sounds like you would not have had a problem if your daughter had a cell phone?:confused3

I agree, but she's eleven. Why should I have to buy her a cell phone for the one time a month that she volunteers at the school. Afterall, she's in a building with landlines. Shouldn't she be allowed to use the school phone?

BTW, many of her 6th grade friends do not have cell phones.
 
Yikes! I don't think you're being ridiculous to be concerned by what happened. I think your daughter should have been kept in the building in the care of one of the staff members until you could get there. I'm glad you e-mailed the principal for an explanation so that she can look into the situation and examine their procedures. It would be awful if they waited to examine procedures for after hours activities until after something terrible happened to a student.

By the way, was the teacher in charge that you mentioned present at the game? Did that teacher have any responsibility for your daughter's wellbeing during that time?
 

I will let you all know what the principal says. What really blows my mind is that it was the principal who wouldn't let her use the school phone.

I do want to add that the teacher who heads up the concession stand is normally there and, I feel, would never have let this happen. He was, however, chaperoning an overnight field trip and was not there.
 
If the students are the ones working the concession stand, whatever adult that is in charge of the stand should not be able to go home until all children are picked up. I'd be pretty mad too.
 
You are justified to be upset. I would have been angry too! I have been on the receiving end of waiting around for parents to show up, and I know it is frustrating when you need to leave but can't because the kids haven't been picked up yet. But, as an adult in charge, that is the committment you make when you sign up to work/chaperone after school events. There is no excuse for leaving a child unattended like that.

Sure, a cell phone would have simplified matters, but that is for the OP to decide - not the school.
 
I don't think you are being unreasonable. She is 11 not 17!!
 
If the students are the ones working the concession stand, whatever adult that is in charge of the stand should not be able to go home until all children are picked up. I'd be pretty mad too.

Ditto
Since when is having a cell (when you are 11) a requirement?
My 10 y.o. does not have one.
 
I do want to add that the teacher who heads up the concession stand is normally there and, I feel, would never have let this happen. He was, however, chaperoning an overnight field trip and was not there.
Didn't he have another teacher covering his responsibility for the concession stand since he couldn't be there? Who was supposed to be in charge of the students in his absence? It seems like that's a pretty important piece to the puzzle.
 
I agree, but she's eleven. Why should I have to buy her a cell phone for the one time a month that she volunteers at the school. Afterall, she's in a building with landlines. Shouldn't she be allowed to use the school phone?

BTW, many of her 6th grade friends do not have cell phones.


I agree and I don't think that it has to do with her having a cell phone or not. Even if she did have a cell phone, they had to keep her inside the building, make sure she contacts her mother and again, keep her inside the building until her mother arrives!

I just can't see how looking after the little girl until her work is done is not taken for granted for them-they are teachers! From what I understood it was an extra responsibility she had as a member of the student council, but that doesn't mean it wasn't their responsibility to look after her during that time, too.

OP, it boggles my mind too that they would leave a child alone, in the dark, in the middle of nowhere!:eek: I mean, what were they thinking?:scared1: In my opinion, you have every right to be upset.
 
Sounds like you would not have had a problem if your daughter had a cell phone?:confused3

:rolleyes: Maybe you would like to buy her one.

If the students are the ones working the concession stand, whatever adult that is in charge of the stand should not be able to go home until all children are picked up. I'd be pretty mad too.

I agree there should have been an adult present. This was a school sponsored event so they should have seen it through to the end. They should have allowed her into the building too to make a call since the event was ending earlier than the scheduled time.
I'm sorry you daughter went through this. :hug:
 
Most 11 yr olds do not need a cell phone. I would be furious! I can't wait to see what the principal has to say about this!!
 
Point your finger. Jab it right into the Principals chest. That was ridiculous. I'd go above and straight to the school board. If the principal was there and has a key to the office, she should have allowed your daughter to use the phone.

I'd be concerned about the actions of the teachers as well. Where was the teacher in charge? She should not have left until your daughter was picked up. Also, while it was nice of the band director to let your daughter use his phone, why did he not stay with her until you picked her up? At the least, someone should have taken her inside if there were other adults there. She's 11!!
 
Ok, first, they said they would call if they were done early, they did, granted they didn't call the house phone but they did call. You did not get the call for 1/2 hour. Why didn't you have your cell phone with you in case she called that.

Second, the teacher in charge of the concession stand should have figured something out for your DD, however, expecting someone to wait almost an hour for a parent to pick their child up is asking a lot.

Third, did your DD explain what happened to the principal or did she just ask to use the phone? Did the principal know she was there for a school function and not just hanging out at the school?

I am just trying to point out that there are many sides to a story and while your DD shouldn't have been left alone, there might have been a reason for that and you need to find out all the sides before you start placing blame.

I understand that your DD was scared but did she ask to wait in the building? I think a 6th grader is plenty old enough to wait outside a school building in a rural area, but that is me.
 
If that situation had happened with my daughter, I'd be doing more than e-mailing the principal. I would be up there screaming. No way does an adult leave a child alone like in your daughter's situation. As a former teacher and a Girl Scout leader, I have done my fair share of waiting for parents who are late. It would NEVER occur to me to leave the child alone outside.
 
Sounds like you would not have had a problem if your daughter had a cell phone?:confused3

:headache: Yanno...it's these kind of responses that promote the thread "Judgemental DISers"..... That was NOT the question... It was her being upset with the school... Do *I* think she should have a cell phone? Yes. Did the OP ask us if *we* thought that? No. When a parent is obviously upset, people with some regard for human emotion don't point out what THEY could have done differently, they sympathise with the situation and answer the question at hand, not how THEY would have done it so much better....
UGH...

Anyways...
Yes...I'd be upset with the school... I'd go up to talk to the principal myself and explain the situation. Tell them you don't take it lightly that your 11DD was left out alone, and not allowed in with the adults, or an adult made sure they contacted you. This is STILL a school function!!!
:hug: to you and your daughter
 
I would be very upset too. Please let us know what the principal has to say. As far as a cell phone goes, my DS 11 does not have one. When he started middle school the principal said that if a child really needs to call home on a phone at school they will never be turned down.
 
As a middle school teacher who chaperones things at times, here is how we handle a situation like this.....1) I let the student use MY cell phone 2) I use my key and unlock the school and take her to a landline 3) I take her in the building with me to wait on her mother 4) I stand outside with her until her mother arrives. We are under no circumstances to leave a middle school student alone while waiting on a parent pick up. As a sponsor of things, I know that I will not be able to leave "on time" and adjust my plans accordingly. Sorry this happened to her!:confused3
 


Disney Vacation Planning. Free. Done for You.
Our Authorized Disney Vacation Planners are here to provide personalized, expert advice, answer every question, and uncover the best discounts. Let Dreams Unlimited Travel take care of all the details, so you can sit back, relax, and enjoy a stress-free vacation.
Start Your Disney Vacation
Disney EarMarked Producer






DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Add as a preferred source on Google

Back
Top Bottom