While basking in the warm glow of having not only won a pirate, but more importantly, having taken one away from Andrew, let me update my NYC Dec. 8 pirates:
Rock Center Cafe does not take reservations while the tree is up . . . now we can either decide to do John's and then head over to see the tree and take a picture (at John's they don't take reservations either but if we go right as people are heading to the B'way matinees -- assuming the strike is over by then

-- around 1:30 or so, it shouldn't be too hard to get a table) OR we can wait for a table at Rock Center and chat while waiting. I'm not sure how long the wait would be -- I've only been there at the holiday season to have Breakfast with Santa, where you get tickets in advance (and then of course skate with a suspiciously different-looking and skinnier Santa than the one who came by your table earlier -- ah, for the days when my kids were younger).
Let me know what you guys think!!!!!