Can there really be nostalgia for something that opened in 1990? Can something from 1990 really be a classic?
Jaws was a fun little ride... and a huge waste of space. I don't dislike the ride but if they're going to build something awesome there I'll help fill in Amity Harbor myself (and, FWIW, while I think Transformers will be part of it based on Spielberg's comments, I hope that's not it).
Considering that makes it an opening day ride (Ok... minus all the headaches and problems it originally had that resulted in it being closed more than open at the start)... It's as Classic as Universal gets.
Figure Star Tours and the Great Movie Ride at MGM...er...Disney Hollywood Studios, are about the same age.
Similar age Comparisons on the Disney Side.....
The Original Journey Into Imagination was younger that Jaws when it closed in 99. (81-99 = 18yrs.... give or take).
Mission to Mars was from 1975-1993.
If You Had Wings was open from 1972-1987
20k Leagues was only 3yrs older when it closed (1971-1994)
Even Mickey's Toontown Fair that many people were so sad to see go because it was a "classic" part of their Vacation didn't open in it's current form until 1996. The 'Original' version, Mickey's Birthdayland opened in 1988, which means even if you go by just the age of the houses/tents, you are still only looking at 6/1988 - 2/2011, or 23yrs.
Considering many people still see a lot of those Disney Attractions as "Classics", I think an arguement can be made that Jaws at 1990-2012, or 22yrs, could be considered a classic as well.
I heard the news and I was excited, because I had heard about the concept of putting the London HP stuff in the other park. So at least, part one of that rumor, "Jaws would go away," is happening, so hopefully the 2nd part is right as well. Personally, I think it would be smart to split HP, to get high traffic flow in both parks.
But then I also thought, if Universal would seriously consider removing Jaws, and splitting HP into both parks, then there is no reason NOT to consider the idea that Jaws could come back in a new and updated form, somewhere else in the park. On the map it looks like there is land between MIB and the Simpsons. WWoHP seems to have given Universal Parks the financial advantage it needed to consider these BIG ideas. And a successful HP phase 2 would conceivably bring another financial windfall to pursue additional BIG ideas.
I Don't see them splitting the WWOHP into both parks. It's just not logical on a thematic standpoint. (HP doesn't really fit as well into the existing Studio theme or layout). It also would be a marketting and Guest relations nightmare. "Oh! If you want to go to harry potter, You need to go to IOA...UNLESS you want to do One of these Attractions/areas of HP, in which case you'd want to do the Studios."
And that doesn't even get into the issue of logistics from the standpoint of if they DO a train to connect the sections, the fact they'd need to completely rework a large portion of the backstage areas in order to fit a train and make it look right from the Guest's standpoint, which still giving them the needed access to backstage areas for daily business......and the whole admission issues with creating an attraction that links 2 different parks.
And I don't see them moving the Jaws ride to another section of the park. Since it's not a simple "Sets in a show building" kind of attraction, and the issues they had getting it to work properly when it first opened, It's DEFINITELY not worth the cost or hassle to completely rebuild the attraction in a new location.