After 6 days and 5 nights we received Fast Passes at MK; our daughter won a "Princess Trivia Contest" and received a Magic Moment Certificate; daughter was able to answer questions about PoTC and received a certificate and a treasure from a treasure box (she selected a huge purple gem); daughter was enrolled in Capt. Jack Sparrow's crew and has a certificate to prove it; daughter was selected to learn how to ride a horse at Woody's Roundup; daughter selected to participate in shinanigans at the High School Musical Pep Rally; Queen of Hearts came into a teacup with us for the Teacup ride and then took our family to a dance party with Alice, Lilo & Stitch (BTW - our daughter's favorite characters of ALL TIME) at
MVMCP; husband received a pair of Tinkerbell pins... one to keep and one to share. Were each of these moments official YOAMD prizes? No. Was it magical? Absolutely!!!
Pre-YOMD our family has experienced the following special moments on various trips (and many more):
Had cast members give extra trading pins to the kids - too many times to mention.
A CM arranged a special visit from Chip and Dale for my sick daughter.
Had another CM close the Chip and Dale room at Mickey's toon-town, call in a special photographer, and do an extended photo-session with my daughter.
Ridden in the front of the monorail.
Recieved "boat captain" buttons on a ferry boat.
Had a bus driver let my kids sit in the driver's seat and had DH and I take hotos from outside the bus of them "driving".
Been given Mickey cupcakes for participating in entertainment at O'Hana.
Both kids got chances to "steer" a jungle cruise boat on a jungle cruise at different times.
Son was selected to participate in the pirate show, both kids got pirate certificates.
Son was given a bunch of extra VMK cards on his birthday.
Been given special "good anywhere" fastpasses by a CM for no reason.
My point is that most of these hyped up "YOMD Dream Moments" are magical moments that Disney already did, they are just re-labeling them as "prizes".