I have always liked "normal" names- just never liked the idea of having to constantly explain, spell, or defend one's name because of others' misunderstanding. Also, it always seemed to me that naming kids a weird name has more to do with the parents wanting to be "unique" than thinking about what the child will go through with that weird name.
Our DD is Katherine Michelle- we call her Katie for short. Both DH and I loved the name Katie, but neither wanted to name her a nickname, so we went with Katherine. That way, she can be Katie now, and when she's older, if she wants to sound more "grown up", she can be Kate, Kathy, Kat, or Katherine- lots to choose from. We decided on Michelle because it sounded pretty with Katherine, and my very best friend's name is Michelle.
Nobody in our family has a super unusual name- DB and DSIL named their three Zachary Millslagle, Savannah Allison, and Tyler Matthew. They aren't bizarre, but are kind of trendy- Zachary was hugely popular in 1990, Savannah was just getting popular in 1993, and Tyler is still pretty popular- really big in 1995, too.
DSIL and DBIL named their 3 Tessa Suzanne, Kenneth Alexander, and Emma Nicole. All 3 are family names. Tessa is a bit unusual, but Emma is really popular right now. DSIL's grandfather was Kenneth, so that's what they named him. The only thing I don't like about their names is that they have a last name (Beck) that doesn't sound good IMO with the first names. Too many short E sounds all together.