We had Lesley last fall on the Magic. She was fine. That being said, when we checked in at port we received a letter notifying us that the Pirate Night and Halloween were no longer scheduled to occur on different days/nights as had been the schedule prior to embarkation. Instead, we had both Pirates and Halloween on the same day/night and it was too much. Definitely a disappointing change, but it was fine in the end. I don't know if she made the call on this change. We were the second MDAS sailing and I think they were still trying to work out all the kinks.