No flames here.
My only suggestion would be to get into the habit of just telling your DH what you want. No hints, just come right out and say it.
I've had to work with my DP for years on this one. She's naturally intuitive when it comes to things like that, so she expects others to be the same way. And I'm just NOT. She could drop all of the subtle hints in the world, and I'm not likely going to pick up on them. She's learned that her best bet is just to tell me what she wants. Otherwise, I'm just going to ask for a list.
I hope you get some resolution on the jewelry issue. And I like your decision on the handbag situation.

I happen to feel the same way you do about metallic leather. It just looks cheap to me. But you never know, it may just grow on you.