2011 Oct 22-29
Me, DW, DD2, DD1, & My Parents on our first WDW trip since having kids
Offsite + Park Hoppers + Fly from Memphis
Total: $2272.01 (used some cc rewards pts, parents picked up more than their share)
2012 May 4-7
Me & DW go to Harry Potter World (and end up at WDW because we can't stay away LOL)
Offsite + Universal Hoppers + WDW APs + Fly from Memphis
Total: $1439.84 (used some cc rewards pts)
2012 Sept 21-30
Me, DW, DD3, DD2, DS6mo go back to WDW
Offsite + APs + Drive from Memphis
Total: ~$2384.53 (using some cc rewards pts)
2012 Dec 14-18
Me & DW celebrate our 6th Anniversary at WDW
Possibly onsite + APs (hoping for good AP discounts) + Fly from Memphis
Total: ~$1795-$2305 (no cc rewards)
2013 Apr TBD
Me, DW, DD4, DD2, DS1 go back to WDW and squeeze every last penny out of our APs

Offsite + APs + Drive from Memphis
Total: ~$2739.54 (no cc rewards)
For us, the high cost of flying out of Memphis, plus the general hassle of taking little ones through security, has ruled out flying with the kids. We'd rather stay offsite and go more often than pay the premium to stay onsite.