How does Royal compare with Disney

Discussion in 'Royal Caribbean' started by Neptune's Fork, Nov 28, 2017.

  1. Cackyschmackers

    Cackyschmackers DIS Veteran

    Joined:
    Aug 24, 2012
    Messages:
    1,636
    I just learned something super fantastic that I will preliminarily add to the pros list for Royal Caribbean: I just learned that on the Anthem, their adult only Solarium, which is an immense glass covered indoor pool with fabulous views of the sea, is actually accessible to those 16 years of age and up! Maybe some of you will think that is good or some of you may think that is bad, but it is great for us since I will be with my 16 year old daughter. I am thrilled that I am able to share this beautiful space with her. In addition, because the
    Anthem sails out of New Jersey, it seems that it will be a great choice for us in the Winter months. We sailed from New York on DCL in November, and I felt the 1st, 2nd, and last days of the cruise were kind of wasted with chilly, windy inclement weather. Having the solarium pools in the glass enclosed space would be such an advantage. We would not feel we wasted any sea days getting to where we are going. I was also on a very impressive Viking ship about a year ago, which also has the enclosed glass retractable roof on the pool deck. It is amazing for sailing in inclement weather. Just a side note I was very happy to learn. I know some of you may have mixed feelings with 16 year olds being allowed in adult spaces but we can save that for another thread. Lol
     
  2. Denise W

    Denise W Disney Veteran

    Joined:
    Aug 19, 1999
    Messages:
    1,588
    We sailed on Anthem in January 2018. It was 13 degrees when we boarded. Anthem is a great ship for colder climates and it was warm enough by the second day to walk around outside. We are sailing her in July this year and January again next year.
    Denise
     
  3. Avatar

    Advertisement


  4. ForMyBoys

    ForMyBoys DIS Veteran

    Joined:
    Jan 13, 2013
    Messages:
    1,103
    I do love Disney cruises, but I find many of the activities separate the family. On our Royal Caribbean cruise my teen was able to attend all shows with us, but on Disney many are labeled adult only even if they aren't really risque.
     
    TJA likes this.
  5. Scillycruisers

    Scillycruisers Mouseketeer

    Joined:
    Jan 21, 2011
    Messages:
    447
    Having just finished an amazing week on the Symphony of the Seas, my DS (12) has no interest in cruising with DCL again!!
     
    Magical2017 and jenf22 like this.
  6. czmom

    czmom DIS Veteran

    Joined:
    Oct 26, 2011
    Messages:
    1,471
    My 10 and 12 year old said the same thing in January! We loved the Symphony, and have the Mariner booked for next year :)
     
    Sehsun and Magical2017 like this.
  7. starvenger

    starvenger DIS Veteran

    Joined:
    Apr 8, 2015
    Messages:
    2,286
    As luck would have it, the rc blog is doing a live(ish) blog of their b2b Mariner cruise.
     
  8. czmom

    czmom DIS Veteran

    Joined:
    Oct 26, 2011
    Messages:
    1,471
    Awesome! Perfect timing.
     
  9. KashasMom

    KashasMom DIS Veteran

    Joined:
    Apr 28, 2012
    Messages:
    2,162
    This is the complete opposite of our experiences on the Oasis class ships. Other than the Very Merrytime cruises we find the Disney cruises so boring! We moved away from DCL because my daughter was looking for more active cruises. With rock climbing walls, multiple pools, Ultimate Abyss, Flow Rider, multiple slides, ice skating, movies, Zip Line, etc. she's got plenty to keep her busy. As far as longer formal dinners - dinners on DCL are so long they are painful. Love having a dinner buffet on Royal for those nights where we don't want a longer dinner.
     
  10. mousefan73

    mousefan73 DIS Veteran

    Joined:
    May 9, 2012
    Messages:
    2,952
    The more I read this thread the more I am going excited for our Oasis sailing this June in the Med. my kids are 12 and 14 at sailing. Only bad thing she goes intondry dock after our cruise.
     
    Magical2017 and TJA like this.
  11. TJA

    TJA DIS Veteran

    Joined:
    Oct 8, 2000
    Messages:
    5,744
    So good to know! I hate to wish my girls to get older, but it was such a bummer last summer on the Wonder when we couldn't go in the fitness room as a family each day (my girls were age 15). I'm hoping this summer on Royal (Jewel of the Seas) that they will be considered old enough to go in that pool you describe (if there is even one on the Jewel) and also into the fitness room with us without a hassle. They have never been interested in the kids/teens clubs, and we really love our family time together. Can't wait to try the Jewel and very excited to start out in Rome!
     
    Cackyschmackers likes this.
  12. hkriw

    hkriw Mouseketeer

    Joined:
    Jun 16, 2012
    Messages:
    125
    we are on Liberty of the Seas in 2 weeks for Spring Break. This is our first RCCL and we have had 3 DCL trips. For us it was the price and timing- we can not longer go during the school year as they get older- the amount of school work that is to be made up is absurd. So for spring break the price of this trip (cruise alone) Spacious Panoramic was about 1/3 of all the DCL quotes we got for the same week (various ocean view to obstructed verandah). We are excited to try something new and I'll do my best to remember to report back. DD is 14 and DS is 10.
     
  13. Amw1064

    Amw1064 DIS Veteran

    Joined:
    Jan 29, 2012
    Messages:
    1,039
    I have been looking for 2020 as well. We have been on many Disney cruises and all the ships. My daughter would be 17 when we would sail and she never goes into the Vibe or Edge but did love the kids clubs when she was younger. We want to do a European cruise and are thinking of trying RC. We like the itinerary (and price) of the 12 day on the Vision of the Seas but it doesn't look like there would be anything to do on the 3 sea days. Anyone have any insight on this ship? I keep wanting to hold it but the deposit is nonrefundable. Is this something that is normal with RC? Would 12 days on this ship be to long?
     
    Last edited: Apr 5, 2019
  14. Daisimae

    Daisimae Mouseketeer

    Joined:
    Jul 8, 2000
    Messages:
    283
    My husband and I are in our 50s and we travel with an older friend who is more like a mother to us. For what we spend on a 3-night Disney cruise to the Bahamas, we can have a 7 night on Royal. So we do a 3-night on DCL if we are going to the parks, (usually for five nights), to give us a good weeks vacation. If we aren't going to the parks we are on Royal. We like things like the characters and rotational dining, but, being able to cruise longer and to different places makes Royal worth it for us. We've been on two of the Oasis Class ships and a couple of ships in the other classes too. The Oasis class are our favorites, especially with the Boardwalk Balcony cabins. We vacation once every year more or less. Since we have no plans to go back to the parks until the 50th Anniversary upgrades/new attractions are available, we will probably be on RCCL for the next few years.
     
    Last edited: Apr 5, 2019
  15. pangyal

    pangyal #TeamSven

    Joined:
    Jul 26, 2014
    Messages:
    3,916
    This is a very timely thread! We are multiple-DCL cruisers and are currently on our very first RCCL cruise, on Anthem, heading back to NJ for disembarkation tomorrow. OMG, this was the best week ever. I will say that having the internet for the whole time on our cruise was life-changing (both the hubster and I need to be accessible while away)...I cannot stand the “per MB” nonsense on DCL.

    Overall, there are so many pluses and minuses on both sides that I feel they come up equal, but very different products for sure. We have already booked on Allure for 2021 (already on DCL next winter) and hope we love it as much as Anthem.

    I will say that we have not had a dull moment on this cruise. I will also say that I have not opened even one Compass. I seriously don’t know where this time went!
     
  16. nancy drew

    nancy drew DIS Veteran

    Joined:
    Apr 12, 2005
    Messages:
    1,227
    We were just on Symphony and movies were shown at the Aqua Theater several times. Although we were so busy we never had time to sit and watch a movie.

    The shows on Symphony were FAR better than any Disney show I have ever seen. RCI definitely has better shows.

    My kids never once begged for anything in the stores and we were not "constantly" walking past stores. I found the stores on DCL to be much more kid-friendly and tempting. If your kids will beg for Kate Spade, Chanel, etc. then you might have an issue. My kids walked right past all of the watches and jewelry and make up and alcohol and headed for the free pizza.

    RCI has 2 private islands, with plans for several more. There are many beaches that are nicer than Castaway Cay, and when you get off the ship and do excursions you will find them.

    My kids did not enjoy Disney kids clubs, but have enjoyed clubs on other cruise lines. They do not like chaos and hundreds of kids running around. They like activities and counselors who interact with them.

    There were 3 water slides on the Symphony, vs two on DCL.

    Most food was included, unless you were looking for filet mignon, lobster, or sushi. We had access to pizza until 3am, hot dogs, buffet food, Mexican food, sandwiches, fruit, pastries, salads, and more all day in different parts of the ship.

    There were so many activities that we could do at any time. The rock wall, Flow Rider, Abyss slide, carousel, ice skating, climbing structure, and multiple shows (Broadway/stage show (x2), Aqua (x2), skating (x2)) etc. are available during the day. There is almost too much to do!

    Symphony has 3 pools, 4 if you include the adult pool, and they were not nearly as full of people as any DCL pool, which is disgusting.

    You can get an idea of the price for a family of 5 by looking at the cost for one child and adding that to the price of a quote for a family of 4. That should give you an idea of what you would spend. A travel agent can also find pricing for you.

    We enjoyed the Solarium on Symphony, which is also 16+. My daughter is 15 and went in, and no one said anything. It was my favorite place, and you didn't have little kids parading through all the time like you do on DCL. Much more of a quiet adult retreat!!

    Advice for next time: we told our servers on Symphony that we would like a shorter dinner and they had us out of there in under an hour each night. More time for shows and night life, both of which are very well done on RCI! LOVED our serving team for our Main Dining Room dinners!
     
    Sehsun, jenf22 and MSPeeler like this.
  17. Frozen2014

    Frozen2014 DIS Veteran

    Joined:
    Jan 12, 2014
    Messages:
    3,926
    Great feedback on Symphony. We were just on her as well and OMG what an amazing ship! So much to do and just beautiful with the decor and art work (and so fun to explore).

    Same experience with dining. Our waiter was quite efficient but the one evening iSjate was playing early at 7pm. We just mentioned to him that we wanted to catch a show and he made sure we were out in plenty of time.
     
  18. braycon

    braycon Earning My Ears

    Joined:
    Nov 21, 2007
    Messages:
    44
    I must admit I always find these comparison threads interesting. As many have suggested, your preference depends a lot on you, your family, and what you’re looking for/value in a cruise. Our cruises have pretty much been a 50/50 split between RC and Disney (about 7 on each line). When our boys were teenagers, they greatly preferred RC - we were on the larger ships and the activities and additional teenagers (girls) were a big plus to them. We enjoy RC - no real complaints - but if the price were the same, my wife and I would choose Disney. We enjoy the rotational dining, and have generally preferred Disney’s dining, characters, ship aesthetics, spa, service level (although both are generally very good) and, despite some other enthusiastic perspectives in this thread, we enjoy the Disney shows more. We also find Castaway Cay superior to RC’s Labadee or Coco Cay (perhaps this changes with the new version of Coco). So, although everyone is entitled to their opinion, I adamantly disagree that RC is better and certainly not - IMHO - significantly so.

    However, they definitely don’t cost the same, as has been pointed out repeatedly. It’s not even close, and this really can make Disney a tough choice. Disney is welcome to charge what they want - and God knows they do - but the expense means we look at other options. The value equation, therefore, is more complex. RC is much more accessible, has more ships, more itineraries, and also offers a great vacation. We have a 7-night Southern Caribbean cruise planned late this summer on Freedom of the Seas, and we’re excited about it. It was about the same price as a 4-nighter on the Dream. We’ve done Nassau, but never the ABC islands and never San Juan. So, 3 more nights on a totally new itinerary, on a very good ship? Well, we’re excited to be back on RC for this. Now, we also have a reservation for Disney’s Fantasy in 2020, but it’s a 5-night cruise that’s a bit more affordable than that ship’s typical 7-night EC or WC. We are looking forward to that, too, but boy it would be nice to be on a 7-nighter. We keep hoping the new ships will drive Disney’s prices down a bit, but nothing really seems to do that.

    We are also planning to do Alaska in the future but, because we aren’t lottery winners, we will probably be sailing Princess or RC. I look at Disney’s Alaska prices, and I just laugh. I love the Wonder, but I’m pretty sure I don’t love it that much.

    In short, you can’t go wrong with either cruise line in our opinion. Really great, albeit quite different, experiences. It’s what works for you and your family. I don’t begrudge anyone their opinion on either cruise line, but the short for us is, although we prefer Disney, the Disney ticket price means we’re going to continue to cruise on RC, Princess, and other cruise lines, as well.
     
    starvenger likes this.
  19. mousefan73

    mousefan73 DIS Veteran

    Joined:
    May 9, 2012
    Messages:
    2,952

    That's too funny. I also laughted when I saw the Norway DCL cruise prices.. we are in Europe and that was on my bucket list. we love disney but not that much.. it's realy crazy and people pay.
     
    mevelandry and braycon like this.
  20. John VN

    John VN DIS Cast Member

    Joined:
    Aug 2, 2003
    Messages:
    5,434
    Value for length of cruise has become priority 1 as we age. Really enjoyed DCL years ago because at the time the co$t was fortunately not the major end-all part of the equation. SPLURGE if the budget allows since it's really neat to experience the MK Fireworks while in the Kingdom rather than across the water plus there might not be another opportunity to do so. We have a 7 night western Nov. cruise and again going with Value-4-Length so jumping to a new cruise line for us.
     
    mevelandry and braycon like this.
  21. mevelandry

    mevelandry DIS Veteran

    Joined:
    Aug 22, 2013
    Messages:
    6,927
    "Value-4-length" ...DH and I are getting there too. I thought I had convinced my DH to try one of the new DCL ships in 2021 or 2023...

    But after our cruise last week (which was a 4 nights on Carnival & was pretty awesome), he told me point blank: "Why pay 2000$ to go 3 nights on a DCL ship when we can get a very good 7 nights cruise on another cruise line for the same price?"

    I can see his point... I guess we'll see. If the new DCL ships turn out to be carbon copies of the Dream/Fantasy, maybe I'll change my mind.
     

Share This Page