Thought I could get some knowledge/tips on here.
The most important thing isn't HOW you save; it's THAT you save. Some methods will bring you a better return, more security, whatever -- but
doing it is #1 on the list. You'll always find something that you'd rather do with your money (or something that you think you have to do with your money), and you'll always be able to rationalize why you can't do it for another year or two (you'll find another reason in another year or two), but starting right now is the best option. If you can't save
something each month, you're living beyond your means; and the only answer is to downsize your lifestyle a bit -- I know, easier said than done.
We have the majority of our savings invested here and there. We've earmarked a portion of it as "college savings", but we keep it in our names. Our 17-year old is very mature and reasonable when it comes to money, but she doesn't need the temptation of having all that money available to her. I could see her rationalizing buying a new car or renting an apartment (instead of a less expensive dorm) and telling herself that she'll borrow for her tuition -- it's easy to pay back student loans, after all, isn't it? Lots of things are very easy 'til you start doing them yourself.
Another reason to keep the money in your name: If you're likely to get some financial aid, the "powers that be" will take a smaller percentage from parents' accounts than from the child's account.
In addition to what we've saved, we have another plan: My husband and I have been in our professional jobs for 23 years and 20 years, and we've been saving aggressively for retirement during that time -- our 401Ks have taken a hit in recent years, but they are still well-funded. Our back-up plan is to STOP contributing to them for the years that our children are in college. This would give us a huge "raise", yet our 401Ks would remain untouched and (hopefully) would continue to gain. This is a possibility for us only because we are well ahead of the curve on retirement savings.
Another big point has been making it clear from early on to our kids that they will be responsible for their own spending money. We pay tuition, up to the cost of room and board at the school for living, and half of their books. The rest is up to them. Hopefully our kids won't have loans, but I think it's important to make it clear what they'll be responsible for taking out in their own name if they do. We also have laid out some of the parameters of the "scholarhip" they are getting from us.
Yeah, I agree that it's wise to let your kids know exactly what you can /will pay. And help them understand what they need to do to manage their part of the financial costs of college -- don't assume that an 18-year old knows what it means to take on a loan or how much college will cost in addition to just the tuition. Especially for their first year, they need guidance.
We have savings accounts for the kids that we put all their birthday money into & extra gifts here and there. I add a certain amount every paycheck to each of their accounts. We don't put much faith into college after seeing so many of my family members go through years and years of it to only end up at a mediocre job that had nothing to do with their majors anyways. My husband never went to college a day in his life (heck, barely graduated highschool) and has an excellent job just by working his way up in the company. Hopefully there will be scholarships as well if my children do decide to take that route in life.
I think you're dead-wrong not to put more faith in the value of a college degree. My husband and I have each had back hundred-fold every penny we spent on our educations. The key is in choosing a major that'll actually lead to a job and a paycheck. Not all degrees are equal.
I know plenty of people my age who are living comfortable middle-class lives without college, but the world is changing. Our children won't be able to pull off that same feat: The world is a harder, less-forgiving place these days, and they need
some form of job training or college after high school to have a shot at middle-class.
Scholarships are far from a sure thing. Hope for them, push the kids to search and apply for them, but never assume they'll come through. If they do, you win -- you get to use the money for something else; but it's better to have the money saved and not need it than to need it and not have it.
My hubby and I don't have kids yet but we don't plan on saving for our kids college fund either.
We were the ones that decided to make the big step and decide to go to college, therefore, we should be the ones to pay for college. I would have NEVER expected my parents to put their money towards my education.
However, what we did decide on was that we would help pay for their books and some of their living expenses while going to college so they wouldn't focus too much on working while going to school.
Right now we just have DH's student loan (I payed mine off the year after I graduated college) and we still have a couple years till his is finally paid off. We pay extra on our mortgage each month, don't have any car payments...yet (will need a new vehicle sometime soon) so right now we're doing pretty good. Retirement funds are looking good, will be increasing my simple ira after I receive my raise soon.
College is significantly more expensive than it was back when I paid my own way through. Not saving something for your kids' college education means they'll almost certainly have loans, and that just makes their lives more difficult as they start out on their own. I'd rather live in a smaller house and drive an older car (or make similar choices) than to tell my kids, "Good luck, you're on your own for college!"
This may seem different to you when you actually have children of your own. Saying hypothetically, "Work hard! You can do it yourself!" is one thing. Once you know your child, understand his strengths and weaknesses, want to help him succeed -- it's harder to take a hard "Pull up those boot straps" approach when you're thinking of your own, real, flesh-and-blood child whom you've loved for years.