Let me start by saying that decorating my band did NOT go as planned. It turned out okay in the end but not before I almost had a nervous breakdown!
After flip-flopping ideas for the past 8 months or so, I finally decided I wanted to do bright stripes on my magic band. I went to CVS and found the colors I wanted, and it happened to be some of the cheapest polish they had

.
I'm not really sure where I went wrong. Maybe because the polish was cheap? Maybe because I didn't do a base coat first? Hopefully someone can identify what I did wrong so people can learn from my mistakes
I used painter's tape to protect the gray border and to help me line up my stripes. That part worked really well. I got nice neat lines.
At this point I had done my blue and purple stripes:
Before I even completely finished I knew I didn't like it. I finished it anyway just to see what it would look like finished but I had already decided I would take the polish off and try using some of my Essie colors instead. The colors just didn't look the same on top of my pink band as they did in the bottles and the polish was puffy and looked like it would peel off at any moment. I figured it was no big deal to start over since others had no problem using nail polish remover and starting again....
I had a really hard time getting the polish off. I went through probably six cotton balls of nail polish remover. When I got off as much as I could, the band was no longer pink but an ugly faded/stained peach-like color that just looked dirty. I could still see the faded stripes and my band looked like garbage. Cue panic attack.
I knew I'd need something dark to cover this mess, so I chose one of my favorite dark-pink Essie colors and slathered three coats on top. It covered pretty well, but I could still see some lines underneath from the stripes so I decided to do white dots on top to distract from the stripes. And what do you know-- I accidentally ended up with a Minnie Mouse band!
I finished it off with a layer of base-coat and some sparkles over the Mickey head. So I suppose all's well that ends well. I'm happy with the band in the end. But if anyone knows what I did wrong I would love to know!