I voted other but it's really a cross between price and other. The "other" for me is SPACE!
We have stayed on site also, as my siggie tells, and love it. But there are 5 of us, kids ages 8-15. I would love to stay at one of the monorail resorts, but then we only have one bathroom. Two rooms is rediculous price wise.
We did POR when we had the
free dining deal. As much as I loved free dining, we were SO uncomfortable in that room. Maybe it would work at a deluxe resort, I don't know.
For our Easter 09 trip, I thought about staying at one of the values(even though we don't like the values as much) and getting two rooms. I like the idea of the family suites, but then we have the one bathroom problem again. They couldn't give me a price,ofcourse, but they could give me what was this year. $129 plus tax a night for each room!! Whew!
So, again, I looked to offsite. We are getting a 3 bedroom condo in Windsor Hills, which has a better pool than most of the resorts, for $125 plus tax. That is a HUGE difference. And we'll have two bathrooms, 3 tv's, washer/dryer so I don't have to pack as much, and the place is decorated more like Disney than the Disney resorts.
With a price like that, I don't think I'll worry about $11 a day to park.
If the 2 bedrooms at WDW were a little more reasonable in price, I might think about it. Even renting points, for our 9 nights, it's at least $3500 (over $5000 for Easter time) compared to my $1271. And I get an extra bedroom.
There's just no contest.