dianeschlicht
<font color=blue>DVC-Trivia Contest, Apr-2006: Hon
- Joined
- Nov 22, 2000
- Messages
- 36,449
For timeshares there can be restrictions on service animals but it depends on specifics. Timeshares come MORE under the condo rules than the hotel rules. With the set up of DVC, it's hard to know how they fall within the ADA. For example, several of the Marriott's restrict (at least on paper) service animals. They require insurance, prior notification and approval, reserve the right to charge the owner for cleaning, install liability to the owner if there is a problem with the pet, etc.JimC said:It is not an exception, service animals are permitted by law. Disney does a great job in accommodating them and making both guests (two and four legged) feel welcome.
I have seen several service animals on Disney property (our own daughter's excluded) and on DCL. Cash, a service animal for another guest, was on the Panama Canal Cruise.
dianeschlicht said:The guide dogs at OKW that I referred to in my earlier post do not go to the parks with these particular guests. The reason is they feel the heat is too hard on them. Instead, they hire a personal guide who takes them around the parks.
rayelias said:We visit roughly 3-4X a year and our last visit was the first time we saw a service dog. Actually, it was in "training." We have a friend with a service dog, and it always amazes me the discipline that the dog has. It was very interesting to watch a dog in "training" as compared to one who is in service. I would bet that WDW is a perfect "test" to see how the animals handle large crowds.
From a purely statistical standpoint, I would be interested to learn the % of the general population who has a service pet. The reason I ask is there APPEARS (non-scientific) to be an extraordinarily large percentage of differently-abled people who visit WDW, based on the # of wheelchairs, etc. I've seen THOUSANDS of people in wheelchairs (yes, I know that many of them, in "real life" have never even sat in a wheelchair before setting foot on WDW property - such a shame for the people who REALLY need it). But, I've only seen one service dog. I've noticed several people who have difficulty hearing making use of the teleprompters (sorry, don't know the technical name) in the attractions.
I find it curious that people with vision problems don't visit in the same percentages. I would think, especially since Disney does such a wonderful job with theming, that people with vision problems would absolutely LOVE the experience. The "feel" of the streets in the different lands, the change in smells in the different lands, the change in sounds in the different lands, etc.
Perhaps, I haven't been paying that much attention. Again, it SEEMS that a considerably higher % of physically disabled and hearing disabled people visit WDW than vision disabled.
Dean said:For timeshares there can be restrictions on service animals but it depends on specifics. Timeshares come MORE under the condo rules than the hotel rules. With the set up of DVC, it's hard to know how they fall within the ADA. For example, several of the Marriott's restrict (at least on paper) service animals. They require insurance, prior notification and approval, reserve the right to charge the owner for cleaning, install liability to the owner if there is a problem with the pet, etc.
HH allows pets in some areas related to the boat slips though I doubt it is in writing.
Jim, I've posted the wording about Marriott previously, I believe you've read it. It came from Marriott's lawyers in response to a problem with people taking pets and claiming they were service animals. I don't know how well they try to enforce it, my guess is they only use it for obviously problems. But I don't think it's as simple as quoting the ADA and saying that all timeshares have to conform the same way hotels do. As I acknowledged, Disney may be different based on the scope of their hotel type rentals.JimC said:Under the ADA when the resorts are listed for rent to the general public they must be open to the disabled. Disney rents to the general public and so does Marriott. It is also good business -- who is dumb enough or insensitive enough to deny access to the disabled?
For condos the disabled are protected by the Fair Housing Act, as amended in 1988, which prohibits housing discrimination on the basis of race, color, religion, sex, disability, familial status, and national origin. Its coverage includes private housing.
Dean said:Jim, I've posted the wording about Marriott previously, I believe you've read it. It came from Marriott's lawyers in response to a problem with people taking pets and claiming they were service animals. I don't know how well they try to enforce it, my guess is they only use it for obviously problems. But I don't think it's as simple as quoting the ADA and saying that all timeshares have to conform the same way hotels do. As I acknowledged, Disney may be different based on the scope of their hotel type rentals.
I'm not sure we disagree that much. I'm only reporting the info I have at my disposal and am certainly not an ADA expert no have I EVER expressed my personal views on the subject, at least that I recall. I only know that I asked the GM at one of the resorts when the policy came out. He said that he approached MVCI with the problem of people bringing pets and they came back with a 2.5 page legal document with the info I've summarized above. Whether it'd hold up is anyone's guess but I'd bet on Marriott over an individual complaint.JimC said:Dean, I believe timeshares are covered under the non-discrimination provisions of the fair housing act, not the ADA. Marriott lawyers may assert that position on behalf of their client, but that does not necessarily mean that they could or would even try to sustain it in a legitimate service animal case. We probably should just agree to disagree on this point as we each seem to have fairly firmly held views on this topic.
JimC said:As to discipline, our daughter was going into a pet store to get some supplies for her dog and a dog not under control attacked her guide dog just outside the store. He stood his ground, did not flinch and got her safely inside the store. Just think of the traiing necessary to overcome that natural instinct. I was amazed.
CarolAnnC said:During a visit to The Studios this week, I saw a young woman who was visually impaired touring with her guide dog. There was a man holding a leash and leading the dog from the front. The dog had one of those harness type restraints with a holder attached that the young woman held. I was waiting for my DD's to ride Rock n Roller Coaster, and these folks entered the area and returned in less than a half hour. I cannot say if they actually entered the ride, but I am assuming so. I give her a lot of credit for navigating the crowds and enjoying life.
LTGRAMPS said:I'm a dog owner and have had dogs all my life, but never on vacations. If DVC started letting dogs stay at the resort, I would be first in line to sell my points. Mind you, it's not the dogs, it's the dog's owners, who think that everyone else in the neighborhood love listnening to their little Fido bark for hours on end....
Laurajean1014 said:No animals allowed on any part of disney property.
Beach_Bound9 said:I think I'll have them sneak their dog into our DVC resort and see how it goes.....