well, after a ton of research on this site and many others, I finally came up with a solution that I think will work for me.
My needs:
- 2 phones (for dh and me)
- reasonably cheap calls between the 2 phones, will probably use 10-15 calls/texts a day.
- small amount of data access (to check lines LOL!!)
- something I can upkeep for 10 days in January when in Florida, and 1-2 weekends a month between May and October when I plan to visit Cedar Point regularly (season passes!!!)
Originally I was planning to do what most other people here do and get the net 10 phones. They were good because:
- same cost to call/text Canada. I expect to do this very occassionally for a minute or two here and there.
- cheap, relatively decent phones with web browsing capabilities (this was HARD to find. Most with web browsers were $$)
- simple plan - 10 cents for text, talk, and web. it was fairly comparable to the daily access fee other plans had for the amount of usage I expect. (10 mins or so a day)
- free activation whenever you let the plan lapse (just have to get new numbers)
Then I started looking at T-mobile plans and they worked out better for me. I have a Blackberry and a Sony Ericsson tied with Rogers. Both are GSM phones.
I spent $20 to unlock the Sony Ericsson and 1 cent to unlock the Blackberry.
- it cost a bit more to unlock the phones but the Sony Ericsson is my primary camera (it's just as good as a point and shoot) and it means I can carry less devices. Plus it has wifi for my trips to Ohio. The blackberry is much better for texting, is lighter, and so much easier to surf with. Buying any US phones with the capabilities of my two Cdn phones would have cost a lot more and leave us with more devices to worry about. ymmv.
Unlocking did mean I had to do some slight adjustments to my phone's internet settings and that took me a few minutes to figure out. but it wasn't too complicated. tmobile reps had no clue though.
Other advantages of t-mobile
- $1.49 web daypass with 24 hr unlimited data. I can do with less - but it's always nice to have more.
- 10 cents per call (with the $100 prepaid card - good for 1 year)
- same cost to send and receive texts in both Canada and US to both Canada and US phone numbers
- calls to and from Canada are a bit more, but reasonable. e.g. 50 cents to call Canada from the US.
all in all, I'm probably spending just a little more to unlock my phones and go with t-mobile vs net10...but for me the advantages of carrying fewer devices and having much better quality devices wins out.
I think if you're just looking for limited talk and text, a cheap net10 is good. note that for phones with a full qwerty keyboard is going to cost more. if data is important as well as a qwerty keyboard, then try unlocking your own phone (if it's a GSM phone - not all phones will work in the US and even then you're limited to certain carriers).
E