Any organization that implements a new technology like NextGen will always put the fresh face on and state "it's here to improve the service you purchase". Those same well-to-doers will also conveniently leave out the potential negative aspects of what the customer may have to give up to get that experience.
While some may enjoy the 'benefit' of direct check-in and having everything set, the greater 'benefit' to the company are the potential savings by putting some poor bloke out of a job to save the guest twenty minutes of time (time, by the way, that can be best used in a gift shop).
Automate everything and the special touch (some call it 'pixie dust' around here) that can't be predicted, computatively analyzed or categorized goes away. There are countless examples about guests patting a cast member on the back for doing something out of the ordinary. No need to do that anymore when so much of your time there can be easily predicted (I'm sorry, planned).
There will be some that desire to be fully tracked and channeled from the moment they wake up on departure date, travel to the airport, land, herded off to the next Magical Express shuttle and greeted by first name around every corner they turn. Others prefer to wait and see what the day brings.
Vacation used to be something that allowed you to escape from the daily grid where the employer governed your daily routine. Going down this road vacation will simply be transferring that governorship to another party - and that party wants every nickel, dime and quarter in your pocket.
I'm sure some may think I'm being overly dramatic, but for me there's no appeal to getting off the plane at MCO with The Mouse already knowing I'm there and knowing exactly what my schedule will be for the next X number of days. There's a lot on
MDE that I can forego at the moment in terms of scheduling or providing personal information, and it may remain that way for the foreseeable future, but more and more me and others like me will be pushed to the side in favor of those who adhere (dare I say surrender?) to the system. We're already seeing it with the FastPass process. Soon, if I'm not wired in, I can kiss every service I have now goodbye.
Again many may prefer this approach. For me, I miss the days when I didn't have to make dinner reservations six months in advance. Growing up, part of the adventure of a Disney trip was the bit of mystery that surrounded it - you truly didn't know what you were going to do that day because the choices were wide open. It felt like, you know, vacation...
I'm not implying that anyone should blame themselves for taking advantage or even championing this service, but don't be surprised or upset when the slightest deviation in your itinerary occurs and those algorithms don't spit out the solution you desire.
Sound to me like the execs saw WALL-E and decided that the Buy-N-Large approach to customer service was a good idea.