Due to family illness, I travelled with my son via airplane twice a month for almost a year beginning when he was 2 months old. I know that I will need a flame-proof suit as I say this, but we did not purchase a seat for him on any of these flights. Not only was finances an issue, but he HATED to be confined in a car seat. Being able to hold him made it much easier to rock him to sleep as the plane took off.
Don't stress too much about other passengers. In all those flights, I only had one person get snippy (and my son was actually asleep!!) about sitting next to an infant. Boy did she gets some dirty looks!! With very few exceptions, people are VERY understanding and will even try to help you if you look like you need it. I've seen men in business suits offer to hold babies while Mom gets situated.
Advice for the plane: Try to reserve a bulk head seat if you can. There is much more room. The one and only bad experience I had was when we had a really stinky diaper shortly after takeoff. There is no room to change a baby in an airplane bathroom and waiting until landing was not an option, so we had to do it on the floor. I just did it quickly and sealed the diaper up in a plastic bag. (Make sure that you pack some bags for this type of emergency). Even if you get a bulk head seat, check in at the counter before you board to see if there are any extra empty seats on the plane that you could sit next to. It only takes a minute and the extra room can be fantastic.
I didn't try to feed my son on the plane when he was tiny. I did it before we boarded and gave him his pacifier when we got seated. He would usually nap after he ate, so this was a good prelude to getting him to sleep. It also gave the food a chance to settle on his stomach a little, reducing the whole vomit/mess thing. As he got older, we did make sure that there were snack type finger foods for him in my bag. But I agree that some type of sucking is important to prevent ear pain. (Another tip if you use pacifiers, get one of those clips to attach it to baby's cothes. It is a nightmare trying to reach a binky that has bounced across three rows under the seats!)
The emergency instruction cards are great distractions, too. Pictures are bright and cartoonish. The card is stiff enough to hold with one hand without flopping all over and my son loved it. During takeoff and landing when you have to stow luggage, this is wonderful!!
For other toys, safety pin a piece of ribbon to your shirt and tie the other end to the toy. The child can play with it and drop it a hundred times without you performing gymnastics to get it back.
Bring your own stroller, even if you leave it in your room for the rest of the vacation. Trying to manage luggage, tickets, carseats, diaper bags, DHs, and a baby can be overwhelming. Your stroller can make it easier to get from the parking lot to the gate, to the baggage claim, to transportation, through check-in,.....well, you get the idea. You can gate check it right before you get on the plane and it will be returned to you at the jet way as you disembark.
That's all I can think of right now. I'm sure that others have more great ideas!
Have a great trip!
A