It is always interested to me to read other reviews of the same foods we ate. I know everyone has different tastes but I also think it says something about the consistency of Disney food. DS and I had both soups and the pork chop for our meal and we were so disappointed. The pork was so salty and dry it was inedible. And we both thought the French Onion soup was bland and no where near as good as Chefs.
The thing we liked most? The chocolate cupcake. Go figure.
I know BOG was in preview-mode and truly believe that the food could have been great one night and awful the next. Or perhaps even the same food on the same night could have varied.
I am glad to read that your meal was good. Gives me hope that maybe some day in the future we will give it another try. I don't think it will be any time soon though!
(Our experience is here ...
http://www.disboards.com/showpost.php?p=46782720&postcount=42)