Dining at HS

[webcreatrix]

We've done Sci Fi 3 times and love it. Kids have asked to go again. We've also done Brown Derby twice. We've never been to 50s Prime Time and I have it booked currently. Wondering which is better - 50s or Mama Melrose?

 

[craigkerstiens]

I'd say they're just very different, one is Italian, the other more southern comfort food. Mama's doesn't have the same entertainment value of 50's, but for some they don't really appreciate the schtick of 50's. If you want entertainment + good food I'd give the nod to 50's.

 

[Adam6952]

Mama Melrose is my absolute favorite. Depending on the length of our stay we average going every 3rd night. Best steak plate in Disney that I can find! It's also my kids favorite.

 

[halfpintpeggy]

We would pick 50's over Mama's - love the atmosphere & entertaining staff! The food is comfy & yummy too.

 

[Mr & Mrs DD]

We really like both, but we do go to The 50's Prime Time Cafe on every single trip. We don't always make it to Mama Melsrose.
Just depends on why type of food you want (Italian or southern home style)

 

[CrystalPalace76]

My family loves the 50's Prime Time. The food is like eating a home cooked meal and the atmosphere is incredible.