padisneyfan and others,
My sister and I just got back for a wonderful week long vacation on
Royal Caribbean's Adventure of the Seas (sister ship of Voyager of the Seas). It's the largest ship and earth and being such, it offers things others don't, like an ice skating rink, in-line skating, rock climbing, miniature golf course, larger main pools, larger adult pool, larger kiddie pools, larger game room, casino, large three story (level) main dining room (impressive!), large three level (balcony) main theater (impressive!), large library, board game room, atrium promenade with shops and sports bar inside the middle of the ship with interior rooms overlooking the three story atrium... .
The food was comparable with
DCL, but I like Disney's better. Presentation was impecible, but I like the different selections of foods with DCL.
The shows like the ice show and "Velvet Rope" were comparable with Disney's Dreams. The others were just OK. I'd say the two are tied or maybe the edge going to Disney.
The Adventure of the Seas was vast, but is easy to navigate your way around. DCL is easy, too. Overall ship amenities goes to RCI!
Themeing of the Adventure is definitely more like the Hyatt in the Orlando Airport (modern). I much prefer DCL's classic styling, but the other is good, too. Edge, DCL.
Our ports of call were St Thomas, St Maarten, St Lucia, Antigua and Barbados. We did the BOB Underwater Adventure in St Thomas which is a underwater motor scooter. In St Maarten we did Mountain Biking or shall I say mountain walk your bike. In Antigua we did an island tour that took us to Nelsons Dockyard which is described as the "Colonial Williamsburg of the Caribbean". In St Lucia we did a 4 x 4 Adventure and island tour and hike. In Barbados we rented an island taxi for an island tour, went to Gun Hill Signal Station, Church, Malibu Rum Factory and Beach Club. Wonderful ports of call. One sea day. You could book excursions on-line, by-phone, in-stateroom by tv, in-person on ship. Very convenient to book excursions on RCI. You can even check your stateroom account by stateroom tv, watch pay movies. Edge, RCI.
Well, that about it.
Tina

PS: Can't wait for our cruise!