Controversial Disney Topics for a Paper

Disneyland Princess

Some day my prince will come... or maybe at least
Joined
Jun 8, 2008
Messages
381
Hey guys! Well I have to write a paper for my college English class about a controversial topic. I’ve been on the internet trying to find topics that interest me and haven’t been done to death and so far I’m having no luck. This is were you guys come in, I was wondering if anyone had any ideas about a controversial Disney topic that I could write a paper on. The only guidelines are that it has to have two sides (I have to argue both sides) and that it has enough information that I could write a 6 page paper about it! So if you guys have any ideas I would really appreciate it, thanks in advance! :)
 
The one that immediately springs to mind is the movie The Song of the South and how there are no plans to ever release it in America due to racial tensions.
 
Hey guys! Well I have to write a paper for my college English class about a controversial topic. I’ve been on the internet trying to find topics that interest me and haven’t been done to death and so far I’m having no luck. This is were you guys come in, I was wondering if anyone had any ideas about a controversial Disney topic that I could write a paper on. The only guidelines are that it has to have two sides (I have to argue both sides) and that it has enough information that I could write a 6 page paper about it! So if you guys have any ideas I would really appreciate it, thanks in advance! :)

what about how magic kingdom has been accused of not having enough attractions geared towards boys?
 

I saw this a bit ago, and decided to think a bit before I posted. Here are a few:

1) Disney films (especially the princess pantheon) are sexist, and are used to force young girls into accepting the patriarchy.

2) The Disney parks are environmentally wasteful, and should be abandoned in order to prevent the waste of finite resources (water, petroleum products, etc)

3) The Disney parks are inherently classist, and emblematic of a de facto class structure in America.

4) The current focus on the Disney princesses is excluding young and teenage boys.

5) The lack of minorities/gays in Disney animated features.

I might come up with more later.
 
I saw this a bit ago, and decided to think a bit before I posted. Here are a few:

1) Disney films (especially the princess pantheon) are sexist, and are used to force young girls into accepting the patriarchy.

I like this one for a paper!
 
Explore Walt Disney's Anti-Semitism.

I happen to think that he wasn't an anti-Semite, but so many others disagree. It is very interesting to say the least.
 
I saw this a bit ago, and decided to think a bit before I posted. Here are a few:

1) Disney films (especially the princess pantheon) are sexist, and are used to force young girls into accepting the patriarchy.
I wrote a huge paper on this. There is TONS of info, videos, opinions, blogs, etc. Let me know if you need any help or would be interested in reading the paper. :thumbsup2
 
I wrote a huge paper on this. There is TONS of info, videos, opinions, blogs, etc. Let me know if you need any help or would be interested in reading the paper. :thumbsup2

I've read quite a few along that line. You have to be careful in using them, since more than a few (for example) claim that Gaston is a hero, or that Jafar is more critical to the story of Alladin than Alladin himself.
 
Walt Disney didn't like blacks or people with too dark skin.

Walt didn't like Jews.

Walt didn't like women working in the studio except the ink and paint department, where he would send people to stand over them and look for shaking. 1 shake and there were fired. He then would fire the women 30 and over becase they were shaky.

The Disney strike was a big deal. He became paranoid and joined a Government agency to seek out spies and he falsly accused many people, including the leader of the strike. He was fired and I believe his life was ruined. There is a lot to this one, and it is pretty deep. What I said barely scratched the surface and was VERY summarized.

One of the more interesting ones in this topic was "The Disney parks are environmentally wasteful, and should be abandoned in order to prevent the waste of finite resources (water, petroleum products, etc)". If you can dig up facts and support this, or give suggestions to make them greener, it could be really interesting.

Sevral of the ideas really aren't THAT good, because with logic you can back them up, or they are fake.


Disney dosn't support gays in their feature films. - Disney's animated films are largly made for families with young kids. There already is VERY little kissing in the films, normally one or two from the main couple at the end of the film. To have gay characters you would either need them to announce it, and that would be horribly akward for a family movie, or they would need to kiss. The only way they would kiss is if they were the main couple, and seeing that there are not any popular fairlytales featuring gay leads, I don't expect one any time soon.

Disney dosn't support other races in feature films. - I never understood this one. Roughly 18/50 of the Disney films feature human stars. ALL of them come from fairytales, and all but one is true to the roots of the story, The Princess and the Frog. These are all the countries Disney has represented in their films, or most of them: Germany, China, America (including American Indians, Inuits, and African Americans), Greece, Muslim Nations, India, France, Brazil, Mexico, Pacific Islands, Italy, and Africa. Dinsey is not racist, and if you use this one you are picking a losing battle.

The Princesses promote female sterotypes - Again...there is no logic here! First Disney didnt make there stories up! They were around for hundreds of years before and DIsney took them and made a movie. The characters are the same (except one, Tiana) for the stories. What do you want a Sleeping Beauty who dosn't sleep? A Snow White that dosn't eat the apple? And also what about the many female pricesses that go against this? Belle saves the Beast, Pocahantas saves John Smith, Mulan saves China, Areil saves Eric after Eric saves her, and Jasmin conridics many Aribic traditions. Awful topic.

Disney Princesses exclude boys - I guess Pirates ecludes girls, as does Aladdin, Tarzan. The movies are geared to families, the merch is geared to boys. For the Princesses, the movies are geared to the families and the merch is geared to girls. I didn't think this was even an issiue.

The Disney parks are inherently classist, and emblematic of a de facto class structure in America. - This is very personal opinion. I think this needs more than that.

The ones I gave you were topics I showed my college English Teacher. I ended up not using them because they were really deep, and the teacher wanted something light and fluffy. She did say they were good topics though, so I would consider them. The others don't make much sense with critical thinking and that won't fly in a College COmp. class.
 
If you have some time before the paper is due maybe check out Disney Wars. It's more about the business side of Disney and about some very controversal things Michael Eisner did in management.
 
How about Disney films are antiMom. Bambi ~ Mom killed, Snow White Evil Step Mom, Ariel ~ No Mom, Jasmine~ No Mom, Cinderella Evil Step Mom, Belle~ no Mom, Lilo~ Dead Mom
 
You could go with Reusing Refillable mugs or Pool hopping. DISers can write 6 pages on that, easy!;) :lmao:
 
The Princesses promote female sterotypes - Again...there is no logic here! First Disney didnt make there stories up! They were around for hundreds of years before and DIsney took them and made a movie. The characters are the same (except one, Tiana) for the stories. What do you want a Sleeping Beauty who dosn't sleep? A Snow White that dosn't eat the apple? And also what about the many female pricesses that go against this? Belle saves the Beast, Pocahantas saves John Smith, Mulan saves China, Areil saves Eric after Eric saves her, and Jasmin conridics many Aribic traditions. Awful topic.

This is what I wrote my English 1102 paper on. I had to compare the original stories to their Disney counterparts and bring in feminist ideals. It was a 12 page paper condensed into 6 pages, and written by me, so it was an okay paper, but I think it was an interesting paper.
I think a good paper would be comparing the differences between the original story and the Disney movie. Why things were changed, why things were left out, why things were added, etc. I love fairy tales and Disney movies, so it was a fun paper to write in my opinion, I just wished I didn't bring in the feminist stuff. :confused3
 
I'd go with something mainstream, like how Pocahontas wasn't the real story, or maybe how Walt Disney was supposedly homophobic, racist, and anti-semetic. Something that they will have heard of before, and something they might care about, and there would definitely be more resources on to help you :) Good luck!
 
This is what I wrote my English 1102 paper on. I had to compare the original stories to their Disney counterparts and bring in feminist ideals. It was a 12 page paper condensed into 6 pages, and written by me, so it was an okay paper, but I think it was an interesting paper.
I think a good paper would be comparing the differences between the original story and the Disney movie. Why things were changed, why things were left out, why things were added, etc. I love fairy tales and Disney movies, so it was a fun paper to write in my opinion, I just wished I didn't bring in the feminist stuff. :confused3
Comparing would make a great paper. I personally love comparing the Little Mermaid, Alice, and Cinderella to the originals. The originals are quite brutal. I can see bring feminists ideas into a paper like that because you are talking about both the films and the original stories.

Meh, when you're in college you're expected to find the deeper meanings in things. I wrote a paper on the altering roles of strength in women in literature. It was such fun paper to write. It was about 5 pages. It was a fun topic, but not one that you could stretch into something more than what you looked at because it was so specific with who and what part of them I was talking about. Now the Disney paper I wrote for the same class was 12 pages.

I just think it's a poor idea to write about how the Princess films are poor examples of women without bringing up the stories, as Disney did not create the characters or really change them. Seems like a case of shooting the messager.
 
I'd go with something mainstream, like how Pocahontas wasn't the real story, or maybe how Walt Disney was supposedly homophobic, racist, and anti-semetic. Something that they will have heard of before, and something they might care about, and there would definitely be more resources on to help you :) Good luck!
You could also add that she the Disney Pocahontas is not molded after an American Indian, but Niomi Cambell. Also the story is 100% diffrent from what really happened, as Shelton said.
 
I don't know that an English professor would consider the mom thing controversial.

There is actaully a very good reason the moms are so unfortunate in the Disney movies. AS others have stated Disney movies are often based on classic fairy tales. In the times when these tails were written, motherhood was considered a sacred institution. It was also belived that a woman who became a stepmother could not possibly love or care for her stepchildren the same way their biological mother would. There was an almost, "how dare she usurp the mother's place" attitude. That is where the wicked stepmother comes in. Because this is a patriarchal society, men were not seen as being able to do these kinds of things, but a woman who dared to take the mother's place was. You will also notice that there is little to no mention of fathers in any of these stories either.

This brings me to the second reason: normal, well adjusted young people don't have adventures. That is why in the literary world, so many of our heroes come from broken families. The family dynamics help to provide a catalyst for the stories. So while an interesting topic, that would be more along the lines of looking at genre stereotypes than an actual controversy.
 












Save Up to 30% on Rooms at Walt Disney World!

Save up to 30% on rooms at select Disney Resorts Collection hotels when you stay 5 consecutive nights or longer in late summer and early fall. Plus, enjoy other savings for shorter stays.This offer is valid for stays most nights from August 1 to October 11, 2025.
CLICK HERE













DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest

Back
Top