The info that ROFR passed first came from Vacatia, and what followed was a bit of a cluster.
Vacatia told me I passed, and then told me to send in my $1000 deposit (which for some reason hadn't been taken when I submitted the offer using "the attached credit card form" to place my deposit. The problem was that they hadn't actually attached a form, so when I contacted them to ask them to send it, she told that instead of a credit card, I should send a blank check (!!) or money order to Jeffery Sweet's office (attorney in Florida who handles
DVC). I said I wasn't comfortable with that, and asked where Jeffery Sweet came into the picture, since the contract had listed First American as the closing company, and they just told me to contact Jeffery Sweet and essentially vanished after that without any other contact.
I called Jeffery Sweet's office and left a voicemail (and an email) asking if I could pay by credit card because I wasn't comfortable sending a blank check in the mail. They called me back the next day and said they don't handle Hawaii contracts, and they weren't sure who was handling my closing. Vacatia still wasn't answering, but thankfully at this point First American made contact with me to get my info and took over the rest of the process. Bonkers that Vacatia had suggested sending a blank check in the mail to a company that wasn't even handling my contract.
I'm still happy with my deal of $83 per point, so it was worth it. And First American has been easy to work with. But isn't there a saying about this? The cheapskate pays the most? I don't remember.