I'm very upset about this as it is my daughters, (and my) favorite character meal!
I remember going to this restaurant before it became a character meal. It had a very nice a la carte menu of traditional American fare and it was very good.
However, I cannot imagine going there for the family style dinner that is served now without the characters. The food is not good enough to stand on its own - characters are the big draw here now. I can't imagine what they are thinking if the rumors are true that price and menu will remain the same.
In my opinion, this is one of the best character meals on Disney property. My DD is 4 and the last few years we have been doing lots of character meals. The interaction here was the best, we saw each character at least twice during each of our meals here.
And while I'll admit that the Crystal Palace had better food than I would have expected (we're not buffet people), the character interaction was awful! Pooh didn't even come over to us and we had to get the waiter to ask him to come to our table, long after our check arrived. (The same thing happened to us at Hollywood and Vine.) It makes me believe that the buffets don't lend themselves very well to character meals because you get up to get your food and wind up missing the characters! So, that being the case, I think if one needs to be changed, they should change Crystal Palace to a non-character meal and leave Liberty Tree Tavern alone!
And, how in the world can the Magic Kingdom not have a character meal with any of the classic characters?
I'll be really interested to see what happens after this change happens. I hope it comes back to bite them!