Ive stayed at both and love both. The thing is that your talking about totally different theming here. If you like the theming of both, then I would go for the wilderness lodge, especially since youve never stayed there. Your jaw will be on the floor when you first step into that beautiful lobby and see the stream rolling by under the bridge and the high ceiling. Plus, everything is in one building. Its great to be able to just hop on the elevator and walk thru that beautiful lobby and grab a quick bite from the food court after a long day and night at the parks. Also, the boat ride to the magic kingdom is very relaxing. Last but definately not least is the fact that you can walk or take the boat to Fort Wilderness and experience the absolute best buffet in the world. The food is great and its not overly expensive. They also have a petting zoo for the kids and pony rides. They also have all of the boating and biking activities that CBR has. Im not trying to down the CBR in any way because I love it there too, but I just dont think any of the resorts compares to the WL.