Carnival Glory (Eastern) vs. Disney Wonder (Nassau) Comparison Report In Progress!

Lisa loves Pooh

DIS Legend
Joined
Apr 18, 2004
Messages
40,449
The Cast:

Both are extended family vacations. Carnival was with Hubby's family and Disney will be with my sister and her immediate family.


Disney comes up for us next weekend, so this report begins with the Carnival portion.

Carnival Crew: Me, DH, DD1, DD2, DS, BIL and his DW & DS, SIL, BIL and his DW, FIL & MIL.


CARNIVAL GLORY
Eastern Caribbean Itinerary
Nassau, St. Thomas, St. Maartin


I will preface this by saying this was NOT our choice in cruise. We cruised on our honeymoon and had a few problems on board, so we went with the LOWEST of expectations. I am pleased to say that our expectations were exceeded. I think they would have been even if we had average expectations.

Embarkation: Well at debarkation, we finally "got" why you couldn't get into the port at a reasonably early hour (you would think by 11am you were good, but our family members were turned away saying they couldn't even begin offloading bags until 11:30am). So we had lunch at the pizza place by the Raddisson. Yummy pizza and yummy bruschetta! We never made it to the welcome aboard lunch or whatever they called it. But that's okay, we really didn't miss it.

We got to the port and unloaded our bags. Porters were ready and waiting for them. HUGE HUGE signs that make known that the porters are salaried and tipping is not required. Very nice! We did tip $1 per bag. Kinda felt guilty not to do so. But very nice that they get a paycheck and Carnival makes specifically known that you are not obligated to tip.

We went to park the vehicles with the family in the parking garage. FIL opted to have an impromptu tailgate party. Guess they weren't in a rush to get inside.:rotfl2:

I had read on cruise critic that embarkation is a bit of a debacle. So went prepared for the worst. We brought our own pens as you fill out your Nassau forms once you get there. They do not send them ahead of time. (I had debated taking them from my Disney documents and then just getting fresh ones for the Disney cruise but opted against that as we would be waiting for hubby's family anyway to fill out theirs).

We got to the line to get inside--then they sent us and a bunch of others to the VIP entrance.:confused3 We went in that way--did the whole x-ray machine bit. We had a stroller so our family was sent to the elevator while the rest of the family took the escalator. Got upstairs and the terminal is divided in half. All I know is eventually we had to go to the left side--where you checked in was based on your deck number. (VIP had their own room and then were personally escorted off of the ship. I don't know what other perks they got except that they were one of the first zones to disembark on the last day--very nice since there are 40 zones plus 11 decks of folks who chose to self-assist.)

In between all this was a tiny little island with the Nassau forms. And a sea of people trying to fill them all out. Okay, that was as expected. Then the family went to the right. I knew they shouldn't have done that, but kept my mouth shut. Then it was a fun little jaunt through the ropes to get to the otherside. (They didn't back up and I don't like to make waves :confused: ). Finally we get to where we check in. That was easy and painless. We got our sail and sign card (equivilant of the key to the world card) and were on our way. Down the restricted walkway, up the stairs--then to our cheesy picture and to the gangplank then to our cabin to get rid of an obscene amount of carryon luggage. (lesson learned, carrying much much much less next week!)

Stateroom: We had cabin 6300 and 6302: A balcony and an interior cabin. Out on our balcony to a lovely view of the Disney Magic!:cloud9: We never got to hear "When you Wish Upon a Star". I was looking forward to that, but alas--our ship left first and not sure if it was my hearing, the distance, or what--but I guess I will have to wait. The cabins seemed rather small to me. Especially since Carnival's marketing materials kind of gloat about how their cabins are bigger than other cruise lines.:confused3 It might have had something to do with traveling with 3 additional passengers than the last time I sailed. We really loved having the balcony. Very nice to watch the water, catch the sunrise, watch the ship dock, et cetera. All away from the crowds!

The Glory had complimentary room service as well. The offerings were the cold selections from the breakfast buffet, sandwiches, some desserts, and drinks. I loved the roast beef and brie. Not sure if it was available elsewhere on the ship, but most of the menu seemed to be. Still it was a nice convenience. :)

The Ship:

For the most part clean. The carpet in the hallways of deck 6 seriously needs replacing as it is severely stained. But the rest of the ship was being kept quite spiffy by its crew.

I was unenchanted by the atrium. I guess since my last sailing was on the Destiny (which is super huge!), I expected much more of a wow factor. But the ceiling with the colorful lights hung over deck 5---so part of the atrium was "only" 5 stories high, while the other half was the full 10 stories high. It kind of interrupted the awe factor for me.

The ship has a "color" theme--so all restaurants, bars, and entertainment areas have a color name. The "Blue" Bar, the "Platinum" and "Golden" Restaurants.

I had heard navigating the ship could be quite confusing as some of the areas are "interrupted" so you can't just go from forward to aft quite simply. But it really wasn't that difficult. Deck 5, promenade connected as well as our deck 6 and some of the other cabin decks. So when we wanted to go somewhere, we just thought ahead of whether it was forward, mid-ship, or after and then went to the appropriate bank of elevators or staircases. If you have a "plan" of how you will get around the boat, it can actually be quite easy.

Dining:
We were traveling as a group of 13--all our family got seated together except for our group of 5. We had 1st seating in the Platinum Restaurant but were on 2 different levels of the restaurant. We had to go see the Matre D' at the "Golden" restaurant for any requests. After waiting for about 30 minutes, it was our turn. The Matre D' looked up my seating arrangements. He made note of when we booked (sept of last year) and was able to move my family to an adjacent table on the upper level without any trouble. Some nights we dined at this table and others we dined at the same table depending on who actually went to dinner that evening. We did tip both servers. The full amount to our assigned serving staff and then an amount comparable to the days we dined with the other server. (B/c of how the restaurant organized its staff, the 2 tables had completely different serving teams).

Formal Night was Sunday and was the Captain's cocktail party. The second Formal night was on Thursday. Lobster tail was served on the first day. I am not a lobster fan, so didn't order it.

The food--was okay. It was typical mass produced food. It is what it is. Nothing really wowed me except for the creme brulee dessert on the first night and the warming chocolate cake that they served each evening. They served baked alaska on the second formal night and whatever they did, was a total cheat. Even for mass produced baked alaska. The meringue was soupy--and not stiff at all. (I kind of didn't mind as I dont' like a stiffened meringue anyway)--but it seemed that instead of being "baked"--they just torched the tops with the blow torch tool they use for the creme brulee. I had quail on the last evening and can't really remember any others.:confused3 Obviously it didn't leave a lasting impression with me.

The buffets were okay at times. Very cafeteria like. But good I suppose since I did eat from them.

Breakfast was a disappointment. Their french toast was quite yummy, but they only served it twice. :( Other than that change of menu--the breakfast buffet was exactly the same every day. So the first day, it was good--by day 7 I was ready for something else!



Entertainment:
Wee Jimmy was our Cruise director! A really fun guy who tells totally corny jokes----and really really really has fun with his nickname---Weeeeeeeeeeeeeee JIMMY!!! In any case, I was a bit worried that he wouldn't be any fun in the beginning since he did sound so darn corny, but he really does grow on you. He is Scottish and wore a tux and kilt on that evening---and carried teh "wee" schtick a bit way past its prime.

The dancers--holy heaven! My cousin danced with Carnival for 4 years, so I don't mean anything against them--but the choreography the first night was on par with an end of the year recital. Later in the cruise, you could better tell the talent of some of the dancers, but the first show was just so cheesy and the dancing was bad. Most likely due to the choregraphy. There was a comedian that night as well who also did an R-rated night the next night. He was so funny but I never got to see the second routine.

Happy Cole (I think that is his last name) was another comedian. He was very R-rated (due mostly to profanity)--but he was hilarious. I ended up leaving b/c I was so tired, but enjoyed his show up until I had to go to bed. He joked mostly about the cruising experience--the life boat drills, the staff, the bill.

Justin Illusion was an amazing illusionist. Much better than whomever they had on our destiny cruise 9 years ago.

There were other shows that the family and my hubby enjoyed that I never made it to either b/c I was sleeping or a child was.

I think their dance shows could be improved, but otherwise entertainment was good.

Ports of Call:
Nassau: I didn't think I wanted to get off the boat. I had worked up in my head that they are incredibly pushy. Not so much the case. Sure they offer to sell you stuff, but they are quite polite about it. Walking around town we did see the pirate museum. We didn't go, but it is easy to get to. The British Colonial Hilton was also very much in Walking Distance. I have heard you can do a beach day there for relatively little money. There was a Senor Frogs near the Straw Market.

The straw Market evidently over the years since I have been has evolved into a straw/flea market. I could have sworn they were in some type of roof covered building--but they were in a tent.:confused3 It was overwhelming to me with quite small aisles, so I did not spend much time in there.

We did get offered weed a couple of times. I don't know what they thought we'd do with it with a baby...but I guess you won't know if you don't ask. We just ignored that, or simply said "no thank you".

For those into the Hard Rock Cafe collecting--once you leave the port area past the taxi's--it is straight up the street. Not far at all.

Tipping:
Carnival does "auto-tipping" to your account. I was quite surprised that they did not auto-tip for my son. We made sure to tip extra on the last day, but I was still surprised that even though we paid full fare for him, that they didn't do an auto-tip. Tipping is $10 per day per person, so for the rest of us, that came to $280.

Kids Programs
Carnival's kids program is called Camp Carnival. They have the age groups of: 2-5, 6-8, 9-11, and then 2 groups of the teens. My girls had an absolute blast! The counselors were simply amazing. So many different activities. My girls came home with a suit case (carry on size) full of crafts. They had different parties as well and many themes going on.

Now--they are not open all day long. On Sea days, they close from 12-2 and on 2 of the sea days, they clased again from 3:30 to 5:45. Everyday they close by 5pm for a 45 minute transition to dinner. You can then drop them off again at 5:45 for dinner in the red sail restaurant on the upper level. They again "close" at 10 and from 10 to 3am they have paid babysitting. $6 for the first child and $4 for each additional child.

One night they had a party for the 6-8 year olds with extended activities, but since it was within the babysitting time frame, you had to pay for them to participate.

The only time you can drop off under two's--was in the 12-2 times they were closed to the older kids, and from 10pm to 3am. They also had limited hours for the under 2's on port days.

The counselors were wonderful--but the hours made it hard to focus on relaxing when we kept having to pick the kids up.

Camp Carnival had their own version of the Carnival Capers for the whole week so the girls could pre-plan what they wanted to do. For most of the cruise it was "everything". For kids 5 years and under, they loan you a pager. They do not do this for the older children.

My girls had dinner with Camp Carnival on 2 of the nights.

My 7 year old also met her first boyfriend. This was quite the talk among the counselors. It was quite funny.

Also--there were plenty of "free" souvenirs that the girls got from Camp Carnival. I believe you had to be present at the activity to get what was offered (i.e. the T-shirt was an actual activity). But my daughters each got complimentary t-shirts, back packs, cd-cases (for participating in the talent show), medals with a carnival ship on them (contest prize), as well as more things covered in glitter glue than I ever thought possible.

Debarkation: I really really wanted to pull my hair out. Debarkation started and then suddenly stopped. They didn't call groups when they said they would. So I don't know what the hold up was. There was 1 hour where they didn't call anybody. After the VIP/early departure zones 1-5 disembarked and the self-assist folks (called individually by deck for 11 decks)--they began with zone 6 at about 9:30.:eek: We finally left our cabin about 10am and headed down to the Amber Palace. We were directed to the seating areas in the lobby (even though they announced a million times they didn't want folks hanging out in the lobby:confused: ). We were zone 27 out of 40 and decided to heck with it and got in line at zone 24 with no trouble. We were off the ship by about 11am :headache: and headed to the baggage claim. We had our luggage within 10 minutes!!:woohoo: :woohoo:

So their zone system is good for something. We got home about 12:45. Quite honestly, we expected to be home much much sooner living so close to the port. So whatever delayed the process did not put me in my happy place.

Luggage Pickup: OMG---after the lenghty wait to get off....Not sure if this was worth the long wait or not--but the zoning, times it so that about the time you get off, your zone's luggage is being placed on a baggage carousel just like at the airport. Not 5 minutes after we got to the carousel, we had 6 of our 7 pieces. Not sure what the delay was on the 7th. We might have missed it the first time, but the Carnival staff had also told us that they placed some of our zone's luggage in another zone by mistake. They had all the odds where we were at. The even zone's were at some other section and they had split off from us long before we got to the carousel.

But way cool! No sea of luggage--no searching the luggage desert for the oasis of your baggage! Just stand and watch it all go by just like at the airport until you collect yours. :)


Summary
The cruise was not that bad. Now I am not falling all over myself wishing I were back on that boat or anything, but for what it was, it was nice. I can't say that we will sail on Carnival again or even if we ever will again after the Disney cruise.

My hubby is discovering that cruising just isn't his cup of tea. He hates schedules and I love them. I love going to activities--he could take it or leave it.

We shall see when I post the follow up next week after our Disney Wonder cruise.
 
loved reading that, I'd love to cruise rccl and then a disney cruise some days or weeks later if I had a chance, but work is in the way. I don't think I would cruise carnival a lot of people I know have cruised on carnival and didn't like it. but I would like to try rccl
 
loved reading that, I'd love to cruise rccl and then a disney cruise some days or weeks later if I had a chance, but work is in the way. I don't think I would cruise carnival a lot of people I know have cruised on carnival and didn't like it. but I would like to try rccl

Friends of ours sailed RCCL and rather enjoyed it.
 
Friends of ours sailed RCCL and rather enjoyed it.

that's good to know, some people I know go on rccl every spring break and really like it, and I have almost done every cruise on disney for now, just need to do a eastern and and then I'll try rccl to save maybe a little money till the new disney ships come out
 

Can't wait to hear about your cruise on the Wonder!!:goodvibes :goodvibes

Thanks for the Carnival cruise review - glad you had a nice time.
 
That was great why dont some men like cruising mine could leave it. But he can sit in a tree all day hunting. I guess different strokes:hourglass
 
We are sailing on the glory in Feb and am in a panic. We have been on The Magic and the Wonder --the kids loved it. I am afraid it will not live up to their expectations. I have been on 7 Carnival cruises but the last one was in 1995. You made me feel better. I am trying to keep an open mind Barb
 
We are sailing on the glory in Feb and am in a panic. We have been on The Magic and the Wonder --the kids loved it. I am afraid it will not live up to their expectations. I have been on 7 Carnival cruises but the last one was in 1995. You made me feel better. I am trying to keep an open mind Barb

I can dig and see if I still have the capers for the kids groups and list some of the activities for you. How old are your kids? My girls were in the 2-5 and 6-9 age groups.

(Keep in mind my girls haven't been on the mouse boat yet--so I will get their opinions afterwards.:rolleyes1 )
 
Looking forward to hearing your next portion! And I think your kids are going to be absolutely thrilled with the Wonder!! My oldest will be 19 and she still perfers doing Disney over anything else! :)
 
My girls are 6 and 11. They usually like kids clubs so maybe it will be ok. I am looking forward to the comparison. Barb
 
My girls are 6 and 11. They usually like kids clubs so maybe it will be ok. I am looking forward to the comparison. Barb

Someone just pm'd me for more details on the club. I hope she doesn't mind me copying part of the PM I sent back that describes the clubs in a little more detail. (I still need to unpack my Carnival Capers to provide some more information...)

I think it depends on the ship on what the room will look like.

We were on the Glory and the rooms were quite big. In lieu of a better word--they were big daycare sized playrooms that could accomodate many children.

The colors were primary--lots of red, navy blue (okay not so primary LOL!) and yellow!

On the Glory the room was divided into 3. The Port side section was for the 2 to 5's and was typical of a pre-school play area with lots of age appropriate toys and tables for activities. They had a tv that they had on Cartoon Network on some mornings. The little's mostly began the days with free play and then they had other activities throughout the day. I'd have to pull my Carnival Capers to get the names of the activities though. My daughter constantly came back with crafts. Most activities were set to a theme. I know one time there was Pirate, another was Dora. One day she came with a colored penguin.

The middle room was their movie room with a bigger screen (not sure what it was--I didn't pay that close attention but I think more like a movie screen maybe than a tv). This is where they showed movies at 10pm to 3pm. They had mats and blankets and pillows for the kids and that was the slumber party time. Kids watched the movie or slept.

The starboard side room was for the 6 and up crew. The front half had tables for activities. They had educational posters on the wall (one talked about the color wheel ). They had a candy area where you could buy the kids some sugary stuff for a tube...that may have been in the back. B/c they also had a sand station where they filled tubes with sand that were pens. (I thought that was the candy--thankfully my daughter didn't eat it per my suggestion. ).

The back half of the room had computers and play station 2's. They also had gameboys. I know they had at least 20 games for each it seemed. They had organized Play station time and they also had times called "cruisers' choice" that would enable the kids to play on those if they wanted. Keep in mind this may not be available on older boats--but it could.

When it was time to do some other activities, they would go to one of the discos. There the counselors had access to being able to play LOTS of music. They had dance contests and many other activities.

They also had activities for the 9-11 set and older sets in the teen group. They had a teen hangout. It didn't look as cool as the stack--kind of like a soda bar atmosphere though. It was attached to the gameroom on the promenade deck.

So as far as stuff seeming babyish--I do know with the older kids that they would take them OUT around the ship elsewhere for their activities. Also I think for the 9 and ups--I think they could swim as an activity as well. I didn't have those Capers so not sure what those kids did--but they were mostly seperate from my oldest except during the "babysitting time". One night they had a mardi gras party in lieu of "babysitting time" until 1am..so the 5 and ups could stay up and "party"...but since it was after 10pm, a fee was charged.

On other ships though--I'm not sure if they have that space. I'm sure that for many of the activities, they would just relocate to one of the disco's. My daughter had most of her daytime activities in the disco...only at night...or for something requiring arts and crafts space, did they go to the room.


HTH!!! We haven't been on DCL yet, so can better compare to the OC--but this was the best I can do for now. :)
 
Thank you for all the great info. I am lopoking forward to hearing about the wonder. My girls love music and crafts so it may be a lot of fun on the Glory. Barb
 
LLP: The straw market in Nassau caught fire about 7 years ago. We were there in 9/01 just a couple of weeks after the fire. They talked about rebuilding it, but it didn't look any different to me when we were there on 9/7/07 than when we were there 9/01. I agree with you--I hate the small pathways.
 
For those worried about not enjoying Carnival.....we LOVED our Carnival Glory cruise. I think my expectations of Disney were blown way out of proportion after hearing so many times that once you cruise Disney, you'll never want to go on another ship. We had SUCH a great time on Carnival, it would have been nearly impossible for Disney to surpass that. There was nothing about the Disney cruise that "wowed" me any more than Carnival. If you are a die-hard Disney fan and love all things Disney, then yeah, you might find true happiness only on a Disney cruise. My son was 6 on our Carnival cruise and had plenty to do (never used the kids club) and loved it! He also had a great time on the Disney cruise. As Hannah Montana sings....."Life's what you make it"....LOL. Enjoy your cruise(s)!
 
Hmmm...it ate my post as I did post a follow up!

Well..

let me do a quick comparison. My detailed wonder report is separate.

Embarkation--I found it much easier on DCL. They sent you the Nassau forms ahead of time. They also send you your luggage tags pre-printed like airline tags. No having to pre-fill out information for those. Parking was easy peazy! Right across the street. The Glory's lot (shared with Mariner of the Seas)--was much larger. We parked in the garage and had a ways to walk to the entrance. Less passenger on DCL meant less of a wait for luggage drop off.

But all those things are small potatos in the scheme of things. Not enough of a difference to make DCL a must do since it is just embarkation. Though DCL's terminal is nicer. You are able to take photos. You can do your kids club check-in there.

The glory terminal was just 2 big lines (well, corrals for a line to be held...not much of a line when we were there).

DCL--once you go through the mouse ears--it is on to photos and then on board you go. Access to the ship was roomy. There Natalie greeted our baby--and fell in love with him instantly. (heck it seemd everywhere on board, everyone knew his name. I was amazed!) Then your name is announced (we didn't think it was as big a deal it seemed...kind of seemed very surreal so hard to savor the moment.) You are then directed to lunch. In our case it was Beach Blanket Bingo. They had room stewards in the elevators or near them to facilitate you getting to the appropriate floor.

Carnival--they really offered no direction. I had to ask. Noone gave us a deck plan at check in, so hard to find where we needed to go. It just didn't seem as hospitable. The gangplank to get on board was more narrow...the width of a wheelchair to accomodate them, but still more narrow.

DCL gives you a deck layout at embarkation.

Carnival gives you a side view deck plan with words--so more difficult to orient yourself if you are a picture person.

Embarkation is about even with favoritism to DCL for hospitality and check-in environment.

Stateroom

We had 7100 and 7102..CONNECTING staterooms!!!:woohoo: :woohoo: The rooms seemed to be about as long--maybe a bit longer than the Glory rooms. They were definitely wider.

While it seems a bit disruptive to have a bed in the middle of the room...I do think the layout was nicer than on the Glory. I also liked the color. Very welcoming and homey. The Glory stateroom didn't seem that way. The Carnival rooms all just seem so bland to me. Much like in comparing a Disney resort room to a similarly designed room off site. We like the "Disney look" while other folks think it looks all the same.:confused3 The storage seemd much more reasonable on the Wonder as well. With wall space to spare. On the Glory, it just seemed like so much wall cabinetry...overkill! Our luggage fit into the closets just fine on the Wonder--while on the Glory, we had to stow them in our inside cabin...aka...our expensive closet.

Also--I don't know why the Glory limits its connecting rooms to the 2 lower decks. The wonder has them available all the way to Cat 4 I believe, so with a reasonable booking timeframe, if you require or would like 2 connecting cabins, you have a nice selection all over the ship as opposed to just a select few rooms in steerage.:sad2: For Carnival, I think this is a missed opportunity for many families. They can accomodate families very nicely on the ships in regards to programming, it is a shame they can't do it in terms of cabins.

We also like that there is a bathtub--allbeit a small one on the Wonder. It suited my girls just fine and made it easier to bathe my infant. We had to take his bath with us on the Glory. Something I wish we didn't have to do as it did take up some luggage space. At 6 months, he just isn't ready for the shower. We did bathe him one night in the sink--but that made a HUGE splashing mess for the hubby. So it wasn't a good alternative.

We did like the separate tub/toilet areas. The shower space more than made up for it since showering on a Carnival ship is akin to showering in a tight closet and reminiscent of my college days in my dinky dinky apartment my senior year.

The hallways on Carnival are carpeter in a lighter non-resistant fabric..so it had sooo many stains on it. Very much needing replacing since it is no longer able to be cleaned up. DCL used a darker fabric--and maybe a better stain repellant. :confused3 Much Much cleaner!!! And a nicer walk to the cabin.

For us---DCL wins hands down! For us..the bath..and room size for a COMPARABLE cabin category...was better on DCL!

The Ship

Wow--the poor wonder is showing its age. We noticed wear and tear...some pulled up carpet, some warn areas. Just this morning I noticed something under the closet...like something had been pushed into it and cracked the wood.

The creaking during the horrible storm--well, BIL who works for Northwest Airlines..says that is the "give".....so I don't think that it was the age. We only heard it on the wild first night (20 foot seas) and not on the others...so perhaps it isn't an age thing. We had no weather that came even close (like not even a rain drop and seas at only 6 foot at the most) so a reliable comparison can not be made here.

The Wonder was otherwise kept meticulously clean. They did scrub down the decks nightly.

The Glory was kept clean as well. Though I noticed more cleaning on the Wonder. *****NOTE--there were 700 cast members vacationing on this ship including some DCL big wigs, so that may have been why!*****

We liked the classic look of the Wonder. I find Carnival to be very Las Vegas-y in appearance. Lots of lights and razz-ma-tazz. Now when I was a teen--this was REALLY cool to me. 15 or so years later...not doing it so much for me. It's "okay", but not what I would call beautiful.

The Wonder-to me, was a beautiful ship! I liked everything about it as far as decor. I liked the "faux" wood look on the decks. I liked the ambiance..it spoke to me of traditional elegance. I never really felt any elegance on the glory. I do like shiny floors though (the marble look) and that existed in abundance on the Glory.

The Wonder had better continuity, better access to forward and aft--I LOVED the power doors where they were available.

I liked the rotation of the restaurants--something different every night....

I expected something DIFFERENT out of AP though. I thought the black and white characters were going ot go to full scale color. Now I will have to watch my travel special channel again--but it seemd that one of the color images they showed...was a monitor and not the lights coming through the holy facade. (belle and the beast). I kind of felt like I had been had. But that's okay. I think I had much higher expectations for the technology. Maybe they just made it pretty for tv?:confused3

Parrot Cay was neat. Triton's was okay.:confused3 I can't imagine having a formal night in Parrot Cay. It would seem a bit odd to me. I think on the 7 day cruises they have a separate shared night for this though, so I suppose the servers wouldn't be wearing their themed attire on those evenings.:confused3

On Carnival we had the same ol' dining room everyday. Blah!

No Casino. YEAH!!! Better theater! I am not into the showroom atmosphere. In the upper levels on the Glory--now while I need to lose a few pounds..my butt isn't so big that I should be a tight fit in a seat. Holy moly---sit on the benches on teh Glory. The individual chairs are confining.

I thought their movie theater was TOTALLY cool!

I thougth the Pools were better. fresh water--actual hot tubs as opposed to lukewarm tubs. Not sure why the Mickey slide couldn't be built for Grownups. Not a big deal, but Carnival can do it, so not sure why DCL couldn't. The kids had a blast on it though.

I loved the grownup areas--though folks still snuck a child through on their way to get a cup of coffee or to acess the kids areas from the Forward Elevators.

I found with a good study and practice of both ships, navigation was easy--though on the Wonder, you didn't have to pre-plan where you were headed...you could simply head to the correct deck and get there without trouble even if you were forward and the location was aft or vice versa.

Verdict:
While the Glory is a nice looking ship--I liked the layout of the Destiny better and have fond memories of the Fantasy. Glory didn't live up to what I remembered from my Carnival days and I didn't dig the color scheme theme. I much more enjoyed the home-like atmosphere of the Wonder. And it reminded me of those who did the translatlantic sailings years ago who were the upper class. THe Wonder is simply a classic ship. Wonder wins for me.

Entertainment:
This part will be tricky. I get bored with Disney shows. I don't know why. But I do. They are beautiful, the singing is amazing, the dancing is awesome. But more than 25 minutes and I am outta there. I mentally check out. I have no idea why. I've always been that way. I've seen the traveling company of Beauty and the Beast and I wasn't all into that either. I surmise b/c I don't like genres of make believe in general for pleasure--I like movies and shows with real people for characters. (I didn't like Cats either.)

That being said--I do think the entertainment was better on the Wonder.


We had Mike Super the illusionist--funny, and excellent at slight of hand. He didn't miss a beat when the boat was rocking for his first show. He also did a cabaret for adults in Wavebands--quite enjoyable and some of those tricks I am still curious as to how he did it.

Hercules was funny--but I had to leave b/c of the baby. I did continue watching it on television--something you couldn't do on Carnival.

The Golden Mickeys--my husband fell asleep most likely b/c he was sooo tired. I watched it for about 5 minutes on the tv and had enough of that.

Disney dreams..hubby took DD4 and she loved it. I watched some of it on tv. That is where my attention span went crazy in all directions so I stopped watching and turned me on some Hannah Montana on the Disney channel.:rolleyes1

The singing though as I stated before was simply amazing....

The Glory didn't even come close. I had read some poor reviews on Cruise critic for their performers. The main lady was actually better than I had expected. The guy--not so good. Then the ladies dancing in dental floss....okay they weren't by any stretch "fat"--but they didnt' have buns of steel..and I just don't find an exposed bun all that entertaining.:confused3 They do have a legends show--instead of a talent show. They pick folks from Karaoke night and that was a fun show. 2 of the singers were better than those who worked for Carnival. The assistant cruise director (a guy) did a cher rendition and he was soooo good!

I love talent shows with talented laypeople and that would be lovely if Disney had something like that.

Wonder started a new entertainment--I forget what it was called...but one night it was disco and another night it was rock. I missed the Disco b/c of the whole rocky boat thing :sick: , but the rock was fun. It was kind of like going back to middle and high school dances. Cruise staff were all decked out in popular 80s/90s rock stars get up....and they lip synched to rock music. Totally funny and a great time!

There was soooo much to do on board that we couldn't do it all. Unlike the Glory where it was interesting trying to figure out one or 2 things we did care to do.

My attention span aside, the entertainment was better on the Wonder. I have only sailed on Carnival and have nothing else to compare it to. So YMMV.


Dining

Well it is all mass produced, so what are you going to do!

The buffet was pretty much the same daily at breakfast on the Wonder. The fruit looked better though and the pineapple actually tasted like it had ripened instead of like it had been picked just as soon as it looked like a pineapple.

The croissants were better. The Glory claimed to have made everything fresh on board--but their croissants tasted exactly like packaged mini croissants that you could get from Publix. Not good at all.

At least on the Wonder, I could find REAL croissants at the Cove! The mini-croissants tasted like their full-sized counterparts as opposed to croissant-wann-be's.:rolleyes1

The Pork shanks on AP night...melt in your mouth delish! And since I don't remember all of my meals--we are back into not memorable:rolleyes though most of it was quite good. I do remember commenting that the food was yummier than the wonder. But it could be an issue of taste and just that they had more things on the menu that appealed to me on the Wonder.

The Glory has the Emarald Room Supper Club--they want $30 pp. Well we NEVER tried it. 1. The cost was high. 2. No sitting services. There was allegedly in room babysitting, but we didn't know how or if that existed so we didn't track it down.

The Wonder has Palo--we did Brunch there. I could take it or leave it. I wasn't WOWED by it--but I didn't feel it was a horrible experience either. The Bellini was yummy. I couldn't do most of the desserts--many were coffee flavored and I can't stand coffee. I dont' care if it is the best coffee in the world. Sanka, Folger's, freshly pressed from some exotic coffee bean farm...BLEK!!! So limited dessert choices for me. They didn't wow me. The desserts on the welcome aboard buffet wowed me more. :scared1: Also we were all feeling tired and off. So that may have affected our experience. I probably wouldn't do the brunch again personally. I had the Eggs Julia--my English muffin was extremely difficult to cut with a knive. I think it was a little well done in the toaster. BIL had the chicken cacciatore, DH had the pepperoni pizza (both said their meals were good), Dsis had the beef dish but didn't like the sauce.

I found the buffet hours option to be a bit more limited than on the Glory--but they may have indeed been similar.:confused3 It just seemed that a couple of times, we caught the buffet just before it was closing. That never seemed to happen on the Glory.

Sanitation was sooo much better on the Wonder. The Glory's idea of sanitation was a tissue container near bathroom doors as you exited so that you didn't have to touch the handle. The wonder--you were given a towelette prior to entering the buffet or sit down restaurants. Drink stations and the counter service dining had the containers near them so you could wash.

Cups--I don't know why--but the "ikea cups" that the Glory had seemed so childish. I can understand not wanting to use glass--but I felt like a kid with my drinks at the buffet and drink stations. They look just like my girls cups at home and I don't use those! I did like the kiddy trays for my girls.

I liked they had disposable cups at the drink stations and the lids and bendy straws. And I did like the free soda. So what if it isn't worth $1000....it's kind of like the mint on the pillow--it's the thought that counts.

In both places, there were servers waiting to take your dishes away. Whenever we needed a high chair and had to ask for one, the servers on teh Wonder would get it for us while on the Glory--I got an "I don't know" or "over there" response. Gee, thanks.

For us--WONDER wins...but partly for the food, the rest for service and atmosphere. (Hubby got a kick out of them readying a tray for you even if it was just for sanitation reasons.:rotfl2: ) I won't call it hands down though.

Ports of Call--
We stayed on in Nassau. Just b/c we went on the glory. Though it would have been easier to plan excursions as the Wonder was there longer. The Glory is only there for about 5 hours. I really didn't get the purpose of the stop. I like to give myself a lot of pad to go to the ship--so 5 hours for me is really a 3 hour stop. I think they need to make it a longer stop, or do away with it, get there faster, or pick another port, or something. 9 to 2 is just so short. Even if it is Nassau.

Noone wins--unless you want a longer day in Nassau..then you can just find a cruise line that fits your itinerary criteria.

Castaway Cay---

I LOVE private islands. I just like to relax and find I cannot do that in traditional ports of call. DCL is great b/c you dock there. I haven't been to any other private islands since the days of the SS Emerald Seas and really have nothing modern to compare them to. I had a blast as a 9 year old on that island though.

I thought it was great they moved the kids program to the island. We enjoyed family time, then the girls spent some time at Scuttles Cove. We visited Serenity Bay--quite a nice beach. I had no idea so many adults wanted to be away from Children.:lmao: We spent about a half hour or so up there. I only had the baby in Flounders for 2 hours (forgot a part to my pump, so I couldn't leave him any bottles...oops!). We did the treasure map and got a little treasure when we solved it.

Wonder wins--b/c they had a private island. I have heard good things about other cruise lines private islands, but since the Glory doesn't stop at one...Wonder wins by default.


Tipping--auto-tipping is coming for DCL. But on the next to last night, they drop off a paper with teh envelopes. You can take that to guest services and have tips applied to your onboard account. They will issue a ticket that you can give to your server. It is nice not having to worry about having cash for tips. :)

Kids programs: I will just flat out say that I do think Wonder was better. The rooms were soooo much nicer than what was on the Glory. Heavily themed in Disney magic. Disney programming instead of the Cartoon network on the tv's. The lab had a lab for experiments. They did build a volcano on the Glory in my older daughter's program. BUt they didn't have a place dedicated for messy fun like that.

The programs are open from 9am until midnight with ZERO interruptions to the day.

They have a dedicated program for infants which is nice even though there is a fee. This enabled me to have all three of my kids in program when I wanted to do something with my husband that was more for grownups. That wasn't possible on the Glory until after 10pm. I ended up not using it once for my son at night. We did drop the girls off if they wanted to go to the slumber party after 10pm. We did put my son in once at lunchtime and then had some lunch and some fun with the girls for a bit while he slept at Camp Carnival.

The club and lab rooms are set up much better than CC on the glory. My girls did like the Wonder better.

HOWEVER HOWEVER HOWEVER!!!!!

On the Wonder, they have to be 3 and potty trained to particpate.

On Carnival, they only need to be 2 to participate. The staff will change diapers.

So in a way, I think Carnival is a little bit better for those 2 and up but not potty trained. You have more opportunity for some adult activities. You will get a pager just like on the Wonder.

Program wise--for my family, Wonder won hands down!

But don't discount Carnival as the party boat with nothing to do for kids. It simply isn't true. My kids had a blast when they were on that ship. Even if they say the Wonder was their favorite. If I told them they were going on a Carnival cruise tomorrow, they would be on it in a heart beat and excited to go to Camp Carnival.

The Wonder though is more geared towards families. I like that my girls don't have to walk past a Casino when we are going forward to aft. The grownup areas are segregated on the Wonder. There are more family activities. The stores have more kid selections (a whole toy store while the Glory had 1 small island with kid selections). Wonder held less passengers, but had bigger shops. Glory had more passengers and held less shops. :confused3

The pools were fresh water. They had a splash zone for non-potty trained children.

They had a LARGE children's poll...the Mickey Pool! The children's pool on the Glory was up by the Camp Carnival room, in the sun, and boring boring boring! My 4yo didn't want to play up there. Instead she played in the whirlpools at midship. (She can swim, but likes to be able to stand up whenever she would like to do so.)

There were the Disney characters--we didn't go and line up for all of them. In fact the only one we lined up for was Pirate Mickey. The others we saw when there were only 5 or less people waiting. But this can be very exciting for Children.

Funship Freddy--I don't know.....seems kind of lame to me. Though a nice little addition to the Carnival fleet for the kids. But he's a smokestack.:confused3

Lastly--sanitation--the kids had to wash their hands with soap and water upon entering club activities. This did not happen on the Glory at all.

For us--the Wonder wins!!! But Carnival is holding their own--especially on the newer ships with larger facililties for the children. They could learn a lesson about hand washing though.

Debarkation--EVEN IF YOU HAVE TO WAIT IN A 45 minute line for the "at your leisure" disembarkation from the Wonder--that's still a million times better than being held hostage on a boat for no real good reason. Customs rules don't change from ship to ship. The Glory was heinously slow in their procedure, it was ridiculous. They had 1 hour where noone was being let off. Please! We didn't exit the boat until 10:30am. We were in zone 27. We did cheat and get off with zone 24--but only b/c some passengers were being directed to do so. Someone elsewhere remarked when they were getting off--it was after 12:30pm. I do know they had 40 zones. Ridiculous. Just get us back sooner if you need to. Good grief! I did like the baggage claim. But we had our suitcases within the same amount of time, if not less from the Wonder.

We were in our car at 7:50am and home by 8:30am. I think for Carnival--we were still waiting for the first zone after the self assists and early flights to be called....:eek:

WONDER WINS!!!!


Now please understand--we had an "acceptable" time on Carnival--but it wasn't anything to write home about.

The Wonder--we were wowed. We just were. I don't know what it was, but we were made to feel more at home. For us it was indeed a much more memorable experience.

We personally won't sail on Carnival again. We would personally find it a waste of money as we don't like to spend money for just an "okay" and "accpetable" time.


Now is DCL worth the $1000 difference. Well that is hard to say. That's like asking someone why they would choose the Grand Floridian over the Coronado. They are just different experiences. We would choose to sail on DCL again. It probably would cost more than a comparable cruise on a competitor. But I wouldn't pay rack rates on DCL but I try not to pay rack rates on anything Disney. I would look out for deals that make it affordable for us to choose it. And like Disney World--I would avoid the high season anyway. It isn't pricey enough for me to be "done with them" in lieu of comparable accomodations on another cruise.

That's my $.02.

Bottom line: I think Disney is well worth the money. But if you have booked on the Glory, don't fret. As the previous poster said, it is what you make of it. You can have a great time on the Glory as can your kids. I won't say "Oh my gosh--you just have to go on that ship." But I won't say "Oh my gosh, you chose THAT ship!" either.
 
Hi Lisa:

Loved your TR. Just subscribed. We are taking our 1st Disney cruise in one week:yay: and we were on the Glory last year. The service from the crew, food from the dinning room were excellent the ship and activities were soooo blahhhh, no wow factor. We previously sailed on RCL, Norwegian, Celebrity, Princess, and can't wait to cruise on the Wonder.

Your TR was right on!!!

Neya
 
Hi Lisa. It was great to read your reviews of the Wonder and the Glory, as they are the same ships we sailed on. We really had a great time on the Disney Wonder! That being said, we (6 of us) kind of felt, "been there, done that". Though we were all glad we did it, no one feels the need to sail a Disney ship again, especiallly with the huge price difference. I was expecting a higher level of service on Disney. Our dining room experience on the Wonder was very sub-par. Thanks for taking the time to provide your reviews! Love, Julie
 
I really enjoyed reading your report...we feel about the same way as you as far as the difference..and not saying we wouldnt sail with Carnival....but given the choice I would go with Disney again.... :)
 


GET UP TO A $1000 SHIPBOARD CREDIT AND AN EXCLUSIVE GIFT!

If you make your Disney Cruise Line reservation with Dreams Unlimited Travel you’ll receive these incredible shipboard credits to spend on your cruise!





New Posts













Save Up to 30% on Rooms at Walt Disney World!

Save up to 30% on rooms at select Disney Resorts Collection hotels when you stay 5 consecutive nights or longer in late summer and early fall. Plus, enjoy other savings for shorter stays.This offer is valid for stays most nights from August 1 to October 11, 2025.
CLICK HERE













DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest

Back
Top