Camera Bag

Lightroom 3 or Aperture 3

  • Lightroom 3

  • Aperture 3


Results are only viewable after voting.
one other question...I am new to editting, is it user friendly/easy to use?

Yes a middle schooler qualifies to the previous question.

Lightroom is very easy to use, but it is not a replacement for photoshop or elements or any of the other editor options. Lightroom enables you to quickly process your pictures for things like color saturation, white balence etc. It also allows you to tag and store your photos for easy searching.

It would not let you remove a person from a photo, or do specific touch up work etc.
 
Yes a middle schooler qualifies to the previous question.

Lightroom is very easy to use, but it is not a replacement for photoshop or elements or any of the other editor options. Lightroom enables you to quickly process your pictures for things like color saturation, white balence etc. It also allows you to tag and store your photos for easy searching.

It would not let you remove a person from a photo, or do specific touch up work etc.


thank you very much...I am still trying to learn all about this stuff...
 
Would the student\teacher verision have anything left out of it? My DH said that sometimes when you get work or office for students they are a skimmed down verision. I ordered it last night before asking this important question.
 
Would the student\teacher verision have anything left out of it? My DH said that sometimes when you get work or office for students they are a skimmed down verision. I ordered it last night before asking this important question.

No, they have the exact same features and functionality. And sometimes even give you more for the money. For example I wanted to move to CS5, they were actually allowing upgrades of the student addition this time, so I thought about that, but I got the extended version for the same price as the regular buying it as a student edition.

As for Microsoft, they give you the full programs that you would get in a non student addition, for example, word is word in all editions, but what you don't get is some of the programs, for example instead of outlook they pagaged a lessor email client.
 

Adobe has all the requirements and restrictions spelled out on thier site, in the store. Usually student editions are the same as the full version, if not it's specified what comes in it.

Some companies (like Autodesk) will also give you a student price for a limited license, like a year. So at the end of that year you have to buy it again.
 
Thank you all so much for the information. That makes me feel better about not buying the wrong thing.
 
So if I am now getting the hang of postprocessing, whether I'm good at it is another question LOl. Would I be better off getting CS5? Is the noise removal as good or better in it?
 
/
From what I have read, it is the same noise removal engine in both LR3 and CS5. I know the one in LR3 rocks!
 
So if I am now getting the hang of postprocessing, whether I'm good at it is another question LOl. Would I be better off getting CS5? Is the noise removal as good or better in it?

What are you using to post process? When I went to lightroom from the canon software I cut my processing time in half or more.
 
I already have LR 2 and CS 5 extended, is it worth the upgrade?

I don't know, I'm sure there is someplace that will explain the upgrades.

I'm still on Lightroom 1 so I will be making the plung. I just went from CS2 to CS5 as well.
 
Here is a video from Julieanne Kost on What is new in Lightroom 3. In this series, Julieanne Kost takes you through in-depth tutorials to learn about the new features, workflows and enhancements that are included with the release of Lightroom 3.
 
Problem is I dont have a student old enough to get me that price, so it makes me think that that if I have to pay $300 there may be a better program available.
 
Problem is I dont have a student old enough to get me that price, so it makes me think that that if I have to pay $300 there may be a better program available.

How old are your kids? As per below, any kid in first grade or above would qualify.

Eligibility for Adobe Student and Teacher Editions Adobe Student and Teacher Editions are for use by:

•University and college students—students enrolled at a higher education institution defined as an accredited public or private university or college (including community, junior, or vocational college) that grants degrees requiring not less than the equivalent of two years of full-time study

•Primary and secondary school students—students enrolled at an accredited public or private primary or secondary school providing full-time instruction
•Faculty and staff—teachers and staff employed by an accredited primary or secondary school, or a public or private university or college
 
Would the student\teacher verision have anything left out of it? My DH said that sometimes when you get work or office for students they are a skimmed down verision. I ordered it last night before asking this important question.

I bought the original LR as a photography student at a local college. It is not skimmed down at all...the one difference in buying as -or for- a student is that you have to agree not to use the product for profit (ie. professional photographers cannot use it to process their work which they are going to sell to a client.) Of course, they only have "your word" on this per signed agreement at purchase.
 

PixFuture Display Ad Tag












Receive up to $1,000 in Onboard Credit and a Gift Basket!
That’s right — when you book your Disney Cruise with Dreams Unlimited Travel, you’ll receive incredible shipboard credits to spend during your vacation!
CLICK HERE








New Posts







DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Back
Top