I think it's possible that people would have different experiences (better or worse photographers) and different opinions (more out less picky about the pictures). We had ours done at Wilderness Lodge on 3/4. I had the $25 email, and I'm personally really glad I did. The photographer did not seem to have ideas for where to take our picture or how to position us. After a while, we started telling him "how about this". The other issue was it was very sunny at 10am and we had trouble finding spots where we could manage to keep our eyes open. And a lot of the pictures are white-washed. I had specifically asked when I booked whether we should go earlier or later and they told us 10 was perfect. The next day, I saw another family doing all their pix with sunglasses on. I wanted a nice family picture, not sunglasses, but I can certainly understand why they did this. Anyway, I probably ended up with 2-3 good family pix and a couple nice ones of the kids individually. That's out of 85. But, I am admittedly very picky. If it were $25, I might do it again, but not $75.