How often are you doing cash stays outside of DVC?

Ah, you guys are killing me.

Unfortunately my wife is insistent we bring our in-laws on this planned October trip which means 4 adults and 2 kids (6 total) which takes us out of 1-bedroom territory. 2-bedrooms are just too pricy for my 150 point contract without borrowing, which we couldn't since we'd be borrowing the 150 to begin with.

Curious what everyone here would do
- Pay $3,400 cash for an AoA Family Suite (might be able to discount it further with future AP, bounceback, or Fall offers)
- Buy DVC rental points. I need 2 nights (78 points) booked for me in September '26 for a BLT 2-bedroom Preferred View, and then I could use my 150 Oct '27 points and buy the remaining 22 points as OTU points (roughly $440 for the OTU points and $1,276 for the 2-nights in September) to complete a 248 point booking.

AOA is super fun! You could pop over to POP easily and see all the super fun stuff there too. To me the theming at those 2 hotels is what makes them great to me. While not deluxe it’s very Disney and makes me very happy.

With that said. Ask yourself is this going to be the only time this will happen or is there a good chance the extras will tag along in the future too putting you in this situation again? If the answer is for sure no, then personally I would do AOA and try to get the price down a bit more. There is nothing in the DVC portfolio like AOA so take advantage of staying somewhere totally different since you are paying out of pocket.
 
When we first bought we never stayed Fri or Sat, just Sun-Fri. We would stay on cash for Fri-Sat (mostly value, sometimes deluxe if rate was good) but haven't done that since 2007.

Twice since then we've stayed one night offsite when we flew in late but generally we've moved to staying the whole time on points, sometimes getting a studio the first night if we flew in late to save points.
 
I would borrow in this scenario. I've stayed cash once since buying DVC - we bought resale in April 2023 and then direct in July 2023. We sold the direct points back for Magical Beginnings and used the resale points for an August 2023 trip ...and then a last minute (by DVC standards) extended family trip popped up for Thanksgiving. i paid cash instead at BW and in retrospect, I should have either borrowed or use the funds towards another contract.
 
We only went using our points for years, except for maybe an early arrival night or if we didn't want to leave and stayed for one more night at the end of our summer trips. Then last Sept, 4 months out, DS and his fiancee announced they were doing a Fairy Tale Wedding at BWI/SeaBreeze Point. Well there was nothing at BWV available for MLKJr weekend so we had to pay cash. It was an eye opener to remind us why we love 1bdrms and our DVC. At this point we will only do cash bookings if DH and DDInlaw invite us on a last minute trip and we cannot get a room on points, which I predicted they will do.
 
So I'm curious if there are any thought exercises you go through when deciding to pay cash or borrow from future years.

I’m not sure what we’re going to do. We own 200pts and it’s not cutting it. Our most recent trips:

Feb 2025 Studio VGF 5 nights 90pts
Oct 2025 Studio 2 nights cash, 2 nights DVC rental
April 2026 1BR 2 nights cash, VGF 5 nights 206pts + 24 OTUPs
Sept 2026 1BR VGC 4 nights 142pts

^This leaves us nothing to use earlier than Sept 2027 and even that would require borrowing 2028’s points.

The change from Studio to 1BR is why we’re now running out points.

We could add-on at the cheapest buy-in/dues combo. 1BR doesn’t really rely on home priority the way studios and sometimes 2BRs often do. But with 1BR we could also just utilize the deeper AP and Bounceback offers. 1BR rack rates are already much lower than studios when compared per DVC point, plus the selection and discount depth is strong.

Clearly I do not have the answer!

For now we’re gonna book some cash bouncebacks during our WDW visit next month, then play from there.
 
I have paid cash when going to Disneyland, but would not pay cash when going to WDW. If I found myself in a point deficit then my first choice would be to buy transfer points, like on the Rent/Transfer board here. Unless I could foresee this being a continuing need for more points, and in that case I'd be pushing to purchase more points.
 
We have stayed twice on cash at WDW in the last two years. Kind of a perfect storm both times though:
  • Last second booking, limited DVC availability (possibly even none for non-split stays?)
  • Because it was last second, we didn't really have available points, even if DVC rooms were available
  • AP and DVC cash discounts, which we used, brought the price for SSR/OKW 1BRs below the cost of renting, even within range of owning
    • IIRC, one of the stays was in the $15/pt range
    • There's a good chance we would have booked these resorts anyway, because we're 1BR-or-bust
 
We did a cash stay at Star Wars Galactic Starcruiser.

We bought OTUPs this year and last year because we're in MMB and get them half priced. Technically it isn't really a cash stay, but it is an extra expense.

But other than that, we're always staying onsite with our DVC points or staying offsite with our other timeshare points. If you're visiting regularly, it makes a lot of sense.
 
Since owning DVC - 2000 - I think never. (Disney, HH and Vero). Have paid for one night before our DVC stays off-site and on-site plenty of times. We would drive straight through and booked a room last minute from the car.

We did pay cash for 4 nights in Disneyland - off-site/it was piggyback with a DCL West Coast Cruise at the.

No points - time to also take the opportunity to take a vacation elsewhere.
 
I... was still doing it pretty frequently which was another telltale sign I needed to add on.

BUT.. what I was doing a lot was doing the 1st night in a value or moderate for my late night arrival before moving to my DVC room the next day. A lot times that's a better value than letting a big point-sized room sit empty until 10 or 11pm.

I do love the moderates and values though. Port Orleans DVC? I'm in line first. 😂
 
I currently have a 1-night cash stay booked in a SSR 1 BR for the start of our trip this summer. With the 40% AP discount, it is actually less than $15/point, so it's even cheaper than buying OTUPs (as a side, this is ridiculous and we need points charts adjustments!!). I decided to add the dining plan for this one night, so we could all get drink mugs to use for the following 8 nights we'll be staying at RIV, but you can do that little trick if you were staying on points too.

Aside from a targeted use case like that, I don't see myself booking much at WDW on cash. But, it also depends on how many points you have and how many trips you want to make. I think a very smart way to do DVC is get enough for direct benefits and the sorcerer's pass, use those points for your one trip and then supplement with other trips on cash, whether that's at a Disney resort or offsite - that's what I started out thinking I might do - didn't last long though. Haha.
 
With that said. Ask yourself is this going to be the only time this will happen or is there a good chance the extras will tag along in the future too putting you in this situation again? If the answer is for sure no, then personally I would do AOA and try to get the price down a bit more. There is nothing in the DVC portfolio like AOA so take advantage of staying somewhere totally different since you are paying out of pocket.
Thank you for making me think about it like that. I could honestly see then coming with us every time if we asked them, but I think my wife (and I) would prefer some trips without them just because they are in their early 70s and can't sprint from one end of the parks to the other as much as they used to. When we joined DVC we felt a 6-day trip once a year in a studio would suffice. But we ended up taking a mom-and-day-only trip to POP last November. This prompted me to buy us the Sorcerers pass, and now we are trying to squeeze value out of that by squeezing in an October trip before the AP renews. So, looks like we are turning into a twice a year trip family! In which case, I could see us extending the offer to them for one of those trips.

I think a very smart way to do DVC is get enough for direct benefits and the sorcerer's pass, use those points for your one trip and then supplement with other trips on cash, whether that's at a Disney resort or offsite - that's what I started out thinking I might do - didn't last long though. Haha.
We are direct members and we did buy Sorcerer's Pass, and now find ourselves trying to justify an additional trip to squeeze more value out of the AP. In fact, that's how this whole idea started. "Hey, our AP is good into mid November, maybe we squeeze in one more trip in October?" and suddenly we are throwing a deposit down at AoA. All in all I think I'm fine paying for that if that's what it takes, but I could also kick the can down the road by borrowing my DVC now, and if we somehow want to take another trip in the 12-months it takes to get more DVC points renewed, we could just pay cash then.
 
We almost never pay cash for a Disney room. However we did buy OTUP for a last minute trip this past summer because I had already banked all the points I could and had a few points that could not be banked. Most of the time we find ourselves booking larger rooms just to use up the points or renting them out.
 
Whenever my DH is available to come, we book cash stays for club level rooms at either Wilderness Lodge, Beach Club or GF. We often have to book last minute when traveling with him so cash works better than points for that. If it's just myself and the kids, then we use DVC points.
We have done the same on occasion for 1-2 nights as a special treat. For a DVC stay we’ve always used points.
 
In a year we have an AP sometimes one or two trips. In a year when we don't have an AP then never. We look at it from the standpoint of we don't really need to add on points for every year usage and we also like to do some last minute trips which doesn't fit the DVC model. Some cash trips are still cheaper than bigger contracts that you don't really need.
 
We’ve only been members for 1 year, so take this with a grain of salt.

We bought DVC for one 7+ days visit we want to take every year even though we are going 2-3 times a year the last 3 years.

We don’t anticipate the frequency to stay that high for the next 40+ years so any trips where we need additional rooms (beyond what we need for our family) or additional trips past the first one of the year we plan on using cash.

Cash stays are on AP/Bounceback or DVC discount, so its not bad.

So far we’ve done 4 cash stays:
- 1 week BLT studio, additional room along with DVC stay
- 1 week 2-bdrm at Swan
- 1 week studio at POP
- 1 week duo studio at PVB, additional room along with DVC stay

I know sounds crazy to not just buy more points but I don’t want to be stuck with “too many” points when I’m 70 yrs old. Also keeps it flexible if we ever want to stay in club level or try an off property hotel.
 

New Posts









DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Add as a preferred source on Google

Back
Top Bottom