No experience gets posted here (by me) without at least some rudiments of assessment. After all, the primary reason I post is so that people who share common interests can learn about events they may not have considered, for one reason or another, and choose to try it.
In no particular order...
Competition
1)
Observation Vantages - Wasn't crazy about being (effectively) limited to last row of bleachers for taking pictures. For "viewing only" any seat is sufficient, because the large screens which display the "action" can be seen from anywhere. But, for taking pictures? Sub-optimal!
2)
Outsourcing - Wasn't crazy about the videographer jabbing his fingers - hard - into that softspot in my shoulder-neck where I store all my keyboard tension, to tell me I was in his way. Of course, it was the only location with a clear line of sight to the action, so he had probably been moving people out of that spot all day. I worked in NYC for 4 years in the 80's (Wall St), and am no stranger to a rough tone (or all sorts of involuntary contact; E.g., subway). En route to becoming a black belt (in karate, not six sigma), I occasionally missed a block and ended up with some physical evidence (like a black eye, or jammed thumb). But, I have not actually been deliberately touched by a stranger (without my permission) in so long, it stuck in my mind. Who knows, maybe it is the only approach that works. Still, I thought to myself, at the time, that, since the school is effectively in the hospitality business, perhaps they could provide a little orientation for outsiders who work there. Just a thought. Student project. (Just the thought of the average student there telling a tough New Yorker to "be nice" is enough to make me giggle out loud).
3)
Music - hey - they added cowboy music to the presentation of the finalists. We all said (to each other) simultaneously - "Wilderness Lodge music!!!". Of course, we discussed amongst ourselves what the intended effect might have been to evoke cowboy music during cooking finals, concluding that it must be (a) distinctly American and (b) they perceive themselves as the cowboys of cooking????? Of course, once the winner was announced, they sequed into the introductory music from "Impression de France" (meaning, I think, THAT guy was going to Lyon). Anyway, music can add a lot. This was the first year. I'm sure they will continue to give thought to what works. In the meantime, when I hear that music (all of which is on my MP3 player), I now think of Wilderness Lodge, Impression de France
AND Bocuse d'Or. All good.
4)
Sidebar - this was the first competition (of all 3 I have attended) that had cowbells. Aside from thinking of Will Ferrell every time I heard them (SNL "...more cowbell!"), I thought back to 2008 - Epcot - Michel Bouit - had a tour going to the Bocuse d'Or finals in Lyon the following year. I thought - hmmm, would love to go, no vacation time this time, but will plan for the next. Fast forward to CIA 2010 - they showed video from the 2009 finals - all sorts of cowbells and airhorns - and I thought to myself "listening to that noise is not what I had in mind for vacation" and declined M. Bouit's 2011 tour - which was probably a mistake, because I have not seen one for 2013!) You see, sometimes knowing what actually occurs at an event like this is not what you might expect, and can influence decisions.....
Gala
1)
Wine - The wine at the 2012 gala was a big improvement over 2010. I could not try any of it, but there seemed to be about 8+ different bottles, with what looked liked French labels. My son says they were much better than 2010 - and I believe he tried a least a little of each. Myself, I volunteered to be the designated driver, since I could not drink anyway.
Update 12 MAY 12 - found documentation (Gala Dinner Menu) in a collection of vacation papers - here's the wine list
- Champagne by Nicolas Feuillatte (same as Bistro de Paris, and Flying Fish) - Cuvee Palmes d'Or - Vintage 1999 (hmmm, probably NOT BdP or FF)
- Chateau de Jau
- Domaine de la Coume du Roy
- Chateau Fontanches
- Domaine Montrose
- Domaine Felines Jourdan
- Domaine du Trillol
- Mas Daumas Gassac
- Mas Laval and Gerard Bertrand
2)
Music - The music at the 2012 gala (French music, from CD) was a minor improvement over 2010 (live, local, not-sure-how-to-categorize). This year, music was simply backdrop and not intended to contribute to party atmosphere or dancing.
3)
Food - all LOOKED excellent (I could not eat, in case you missed the back story), seemed somewhat scaled back in ambition / ingredients (no lamb chops), but not in quality. I cannot speak for flavor...
4)
Award Presentations - modest, but heartfelt. 2010 had the benefit of the excitement of announcing the winners.
5)
Participation /
Crowds - seemed much thinner, possibly by half. Not sure if that was by design (that is, making the event more by and for the professional chefs and students) or happenstance (general public not knowing about it). If it WAS by design, then they succeeded in hosting a low key event that did not overheat the small room (former chapel). If it was be ACCIDENT, then they will probably modify getting the word out in 2014.
6)
Dessert - sure, technically this falls under "food," but the whole "blog thing" allows me to ignore that and keep going - was very pleased to see our (DS and I) favorite from 2010 - the maple creme. I was a moderate fan the maple creme brulee at Le Cellier (the couple times I went on dining vouchers) - but this was outstanding. And I could not eat it. Hmm, will have to see if THIS is in Chef Migoya's cookbook. If YES, then BUY.
Also, we saw suckers, as well as marshmallows - I noticed that these are also offered at Remy's on the Disney Dream as a part of the Friandise. Must be a current, next "big thing" because I haven't seen them outside of these two venues. Gala had marshmallows in 5 flavors (really wanted to try the root beer). Remy's had raspberry (my favorite). Next time!! I, always willing to accept that I just can't know everything all the time, asked Chef Migoya, "What is a marshmallow, anyway?" (Answer - corn syrup, sugar, flavor... sounded like cotton candy with edible glue.... my mind wandered at that point - I can tolerate marshmallows in hot chocolate for nostalgia's sake, but left to my own devices, homemade hot chocolate with real whipped cream is all I want). How it is that I am not MUCH larger? Exercise of free will. Nothing else works.
Remy's suckers, marshmallows, and other post-dessert treats:
Miscellaneous
1)
Audience - the student adulation of the chefs is charming, but I actually enjoyed sitting in the audience with Orlando's professional chefs more - because of all their educational commentary (see 2008 posts); I
learned more.
Summary - classic
1) Would I
repeat the experience? If YES, under what circumstances?
2) Would I
recommend the experience to others? If YES, with what qualifications?
3) What, if changed, would
improve the experience, independent of #1 and #2?
1)
At CIA? Probably - it is so challenging to find out the details of this event, I may not have the right type of vacation time available when it occurs. I would LIKE to attend, and if it is held at CIA in 2014, I will probably TRY to attend. I am really fortunate that I stumbled onto this event in 2008. I thought it was a long-running event that Epcot just happened to host that year. In reality, it was the FIRST event, and I was lucky enough to be in WDW at the time. It seems to have matured significantly, and I would not be surprised that as it continue to grow, people like me will be "left behind." After all, I am "just a fan" and neither a professional cook, nor media maven. The latter two are more likely to contribute, directly or indirectly, to the Bocuse d'Or USA cause.
At Epcot, or other Disney venue? Definitely
- great hotels (I didn't burden you with my assessment of our motel in Poughkeepsie. No point.)
- many alternative dining options (I like CIA restaurants, but you have to beg for reservations during this event, as they reserve most of the seating for the participants and sponsors. Pleading is not my strong suit.)
- much better weather
- audience more sunny, friendly and knowledgeable
- service staff (photographer) Disney-trained (and, I know Ron would let me take pictures - he does at all the F&W events - who doesn't make free advertising easy?)
- yes, yes and yes.
2)
Definitely - if, on reading this description, you think it appeals.
3) I've already covered ideas on the event within the text. W
hat would improve it for me, personally? Some sort or press pass, or backstage pass. All I really want to do is take pictures and tell people about it. At my own expense, no less!