Reasons to choose BWV...
Reason #1: We chose BWV for the shorter RTU (expires about when we won't be going to WDW anymore - when we're 85 & 80). Didn't want to saddle kids inheriting a timeshare or having to try to resell when a senior. Like that it will just kind of expire when we do.
Reason #2: BWV has mostly single floor Grand Villas without stairs (top 2 floor offers a few 2 story ones). Person in family in wheelchair. BWV offers the only grand villas that are single story that you can also walk or wheel over to 2 of the parks. Jambo also has single story grand villas but need bus to go anywhere, or a car. Beach Club has none.
Reason #3: View of Boardwalk & lake guaranteed booking category. Are there any great views from Beach Club?
Reason #4: Now that Pleasure Island closed the clubs, the only adult places left are Jellyrolls & Atlantic Dance Hall, at Boardwalk.
Reason #5: Husband a sports fanatic & like breweries, and Boardwalk has ESPN & Big River Brewery. Check & check.
Reason #6: Location central for Epcot, Hollywood Studios, Mandara Spa & Fantasia Golf - son's favorite is always golf, doesn't do roller coasters, but does golf. I need a spa break mid-WDW trip.
Reason #7: Bang for the buck - get more points to use at better price.
Many don't like that BWV has lack of dining plan counter service except the BW bakery, don't like the LONG halls. Beach Club is slightly closer to Epcot, offers dedicated 2 bedrooms that are lacking at BWV, has covered path to counter service, closer parking lot to room, etc. Long halls are not a compaint at BC. Less supply of rooms drives up values too and BC has less than BWV (282 vs 383).
I like the atmosphere of Boardwalk best though. It's so pretty, shimmering at night, festive - love the magicians & performers on the boardwalk too, the clubs, nightlife. The pool I thought was too crazy at Beach Club, people in swimsuits running across walking path when trying to walk over to Yacht Club for dinner, also can lose sight of your kids fast. Boardwalk Villas has better line of sight for watching kids, still not old enough for the huge slide yet though.
We do like the pizza window at Boardwalk & the Bakery though, and that works for us fine since almost all one of my kids eats is pizza anyway. A chocolate coissant, breakfast sandwich, maybe a yogurt cup with fruit & granola, then like to eat at one of tables on the boardwalk. If it's pouring rain, that's when many at BWV are stuck having to brave the rain to get anywhere for food. But that's when we use our
DVC kitchen that is stocked usually with tons of leftovers from the large portions given with meals anyway (never go anywhere without 2 tupperwares & pouch of ziplocs).