I'm doing the same type of planning... but not even close to being engaged

But hey.. a girl can dream right! Have to have something to go along with that Disney wedding I'm planning too... heh!
I've narrowed it down too:
WL Honeymoon suite: Love the feel of the resort... love the jacuzzi tub... love the CL privledges. Not a huge fan of the view (wooded view, with two that "face" the MK) but can't complain about anything else!
Poly Lagoon View CL: I'm not a fan of how the honeymoon suite is not in the Hawaii/CL longhouse so I crossed that one off my list. I love the LVC rooms though. The view is breathtaking... the CL lounge is top notch... and the resort has such an amazing/romantic feeling.
GF Honeymoon suites: These suites are amazing... but so is that price tag lol! I've noticed these rooms don't have balconies but several windows that offer amazing views. It's main building concierge... which is a very nice touch. Still a very expensive price tag in my book.
All three of these resorts are in the process/has completed full room renovations including flat screen TVs, new furniture/decor, and new linens. This is a HUGE advantage in my book... that give them the 1-up over some of the boardwalk area hotels.
Yacht Club Lagoon view: Love this resort for the pool... location... and the amazing view. Perfect area to just wander around, grab a great drink, and soak in the moment.
DVC resorts: I have not ruled out the DVC resorts either. The 1-bedrooms are fantastic with the jacuzzi tubs, king beds, seperate living area, etc. I would definately consider SSR (more of an adult/privacy feel).